Less than 5 hrs after receiving my spanking new iPad, I rebooted it and encountered the dreaded endless loop. After the initial "***" shock, I went about restoring my new iPad using everything I had learned through my iPhone 4S ordeal earlier.
Since I had not had a chance to do an iTunes backup for the new iPad, I attempted to restore to an iCloud backup. The restore was stuck at "9 minutes remaining". The only option left was to restore as NEW. Sure enough, my new iPad came back to life, albeit losing 5 hours' worth of customizations.
I'm amazed that Apple hasn't released an update to fix this glarring issue with iOS 5.1. Getting into an endless reboot loop 5 hours after receiving a new iPad is just mind-boggling. Not even the worst of Microsoft's 1.0 products are that bad. If not for my dislike of Android copycats and their inferior user experiences, I would have been tempted to switch to the "dark" side.
I've thought about what iCloud is good for and not good for. I've come to the following conclusions:
1) iCloud is good for sync-ing of things like contacts, bookmarks, notes, etc.
2) iCloud as a general backup/restore technology is hopelessly immature and not ready for prime time. If you really think about it, if you have 5GB worth of apps and data saved to iCloud, when doing a full restore, all that 5GB will need to be downloaded to your iPhone/iPad, and then applied to your device. Let's say Apple has 100 mil users who on average has 5GB worth of stuff saved to iCloud, and all those users update to the latest iOS at more or less the same time, it's no small wonder that the whole iCloud restore thing is a disaster. Given that iCloud doesn't allow the restoring of individual apps, and provides no way of accessing individual files for each app, as a backup/restore technology, it's pretty much useless. Case in a point, I still have my full iPhone 4S and iPad backups on iCloud but have no way of using any of this data. Contrast this to the Dropbox approach where you can access your cloud stuff via multiple devices down to the file level, and it's easy to see why iCloud's blackbox approach is pretty much useless in its current form.
I'm going to switch all my iOS devices back to local iTunes backup. That way should anything untoward happens to my iOS devices in the future, I can safely and reliably restore them.
Hope the above help some of you out there. Nobody wants to restore as NEW, but when iCloud restore doesn't work, there isn't much of a choice if you don't have an iTunes backup.
Minh.