Users added to Profile Manager not showing up in everyone group

So profile manager was working quite well until I made a change to the workgroup group.

I removed the password policy from the workgroup group and added a new group for the password policy so we could essentially still manage non user assigned iOS devices.

Now when I add a new user to the workgroup group on the server I have them login to the mydevices site so we can enroll the device and they can login but are immediately presented with:

"You do not have permission to access the page you were looking for. Contact your system administrator."

In troubleshooting the issue I noticed that new users being added are not showing up the in the everyone group which is preventing the users from having proper access. Prior to all this I could add a user and they would show up in everyone as intended.

Any thoughts?