iOS 5.1 AAC encoded music with "High Efficiency" is not playing

Hello to all,


Since I upgraded my iPhone 4 to iOS 5.1, m4a tracks encoded in AAC with "High Efficiency" profile are NOT playing.

The tracks are playing correctly in iTunes on my MacBook Pro but they are not playing on the iPhone.

This is a serious and annoying bug because there are millions of users out there who encoded tjeir music this way.

So, now what? Do I have to re-encode my entire music library using the "Low Complexity" profile from the source CD's, again ???

iPhone 4, iOS 5.1

Posted on Mar 13, 2012 2:51 AM

Reply
11 replies

Mar 13, 2012 9:06 AM in response to NetRanger1967

First of all, I don't think "millions of users" have encoded their music in that format...since it is a low bitrate format, good for streaming and such, but using that as default format for your iTunes library is like driving your car on the sidewalk...it works but it is not good. ;-) But anyway, re-syncronizing your iPhone should relieve it in most cases.

Mar 13, 2012 10:42 AM in response to M-J-E

Reply to M-J-E


Allow me to disagree to the term "low bitrate" because my music is ripped at 256 Kbps, Constant Bit Rate, High Efficiency, Stereo, 44100 Hz.

Ripping the same music with the same codec in "Low Complexity" mode works fine and the tracks are correctly reproduced on the iPhone.

I've never had this problem since my first iPhone and iPod before that.

Apple changed something in iOS5.1 and I really want to know if it is a bug or a feature change!

Apr 16, 2012 6:19 AM in response to NetRanger1967

Hi,


i see this topic lately, having discovered the problem this week end, but it's mine too. I did rip my Cds using m4a aac+ (CBR 256) codec (the high efficiency of EzCd) and they are not playing anymore. Is there any new from Apple about this downgrade or bug ? I use Iphone, Ipod, and at home a Dvico Tvix and the best compatible format between the different players was this codec (no m4a lossless on Dvico, no flac on Iphone).


I'm not sure that we may be millions to be in this case, but as it's the ripping of my more or less 700 Cds, with the ability to hear them on different brands, it's a kind of job i would not like to have to do once more for an Ios bug 🙂


Thanks by advance for any new 🙂

Apr 16, 2012 6:40 AM in response to Lampro92

Hello,


I did report this to Apple but I haven' had any news yet.

I'm really looking forward for a solution because I'm not willing to re-rip my entire music collection again.


I did use AAC-HE within Easy CD-DA Extractor to rip part of my collection before moving to Mac where I use XLD.
The problem occurs also with M4A tracks ripped in "HE" mode using XLD on a Mac.


So, there is a problem with "HE" and I'm trying to understand whether it is a bug or not.


Regards.

Apr 16, 2012 7:35 AM in response to NetRanger1967

Hello,


i do understand your problem, which is mine too ... just that i did update to IOS5.1 last week end, and did not try to hear at any music on it until yestearday... m4a lossless works fine, only the recordings in aac+so it's clearly a downgrade or a bug, and i'm not wanting to re-rip neither 🙂

AAC+ (HE AAC) 256 is clearly a good format, not lossless, but great for many classical recordings that are not digital or recent. If not listed as a downgrade, it's a bug or something 'forgotten' in the last IOS.


Other explanation could be the end or the lack of use of this codec ... i did read few lines about it being taken to dolby aac on the poiko site.


In any way, and as you are, i'll be glad to read what Apple have to say about it, as it is, whatever the reason, a functional downgrade.


Regards

Jun 23, 2012 4:29 AM in response to NetRanger1967

Frustratingly I see there are no posted solutions as of yet and am wondering if anyone has in fact resolved this annoying issue. If so, please be so kind as to post the solution online.


To reiterate, the problem presented itself AFTER I upgarded to IOS5 in that all my original songs that used to work before the upgrade (encoded with High Efficiency) will in fact still play in Itunes but NOT on my Ipod Touch.

Aug 14, 2012 3:16 AM in response to NetRanger1967

Hello to all,


Just to let you know that this problem is not yet resolved and the case is ongoing.

I've reported this issue to Apple, and provided some sample files to demonstrate the problem.

After upgrading to v5.1, m4a tracks encoded in "High Efficiency" mode are not playing!


They should be working on it because they contacted me for additional information.


I will post in this thread whenever I have more (good) news hopefully.


Regards.

Aug 20, 2012 6:30 AM in response to NetRanger1967

Hello,


i saw no better result, but i did find a solution : i did buy an App reading flac encoded music. Part of my library was flac, part m4a aac+ ... i did rework from my Cds the m4a in flac, (400 in around one month) and that's done ... bad new : it takes more place on the phone ... good new : the sound is always perfect, as it's lossless and free of any brand (not an other m4a) ... good new (2) : i do encode only once (for my Tvix Dvico and my Iphone), so it's faster.

I think that Apple does not want to pay (anymore) for the Poiko codec, and that's why it does not work anymore since IOS5 ... there was in the (far) past a similar situation with a mp3+ (enhanced) created by Thompson ... very good but noone wanting to pay for it, so not used anymore 🙂

The iTunes App Flac Player was around 8 euros and works well (not perfect, but good) and the small equalizer is fine. So that's a quick and not so expensive solution (compared to the amount of music not readable).


I don't thank Apple for this functionnal downgrade, it's anything but fair, but i'm back now in a free situation (no link to a Apple dedicated codec), and then may be more free to choose between I5 and S3 at the end of this year.


I hope that this can help someone in a similar situation.


Regards,


Lampro

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

iOS 5.1 AAC encoded music with "High Efficiency" is not playing

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.