Different sample rates in same song - can Logic do it?

A friend of mine told me he uses different sample rates in Logic, such as 44.1K and 88.2K, and he claims Logic simply adjusts without having to do anything and it all syncs up fine. Now, my experience has been quite the opposite. Will Logic do this, and I am missing something? I hope so, as i need to re-record vocals at a higher rate than the old ones, but need the old ones for reference and don't want to have to convert 40 tracks first.

thanks

G5 Dual 2.5 w/4 Gig RAM Mac OS X (10.4.4)

Posted on Feb 26, 2006 6:27 AM

Reply
7 replies

Feb 26, 2006 5:56 PM in response to mattdean

I'm sure you can do this, I will check for sure tomorrow. if you convert 1 file then you can check, but im sure i have 24 bit and 16 bit files in the one arrangement, not sure about sample rate though would be a bit tricky being transfered digitally out of the machine to different devices. also brings the question of multi outs if you have a 48k going to 1 - 2 and a 96k going to 3 - 4 does it keep them at 44.1k 48k or 96k? the is no setting that i know of in logic for this and theoretically logic could act like a sample rate convertor (an expensive one at that) but if you are working on a project with single 1-2 outs and not sending stuff digitally then i would say your ok.

Feb 26, 2006 6:38 PM in response to mattdean

Hi,
Logic can handle different bit depths at the same time (16 and 24 for example) but only one sample rate. This includes any external devices connected digitally. So the answer is no. It can't be done and your friend is mistaken. You must convert the sample rate of your existing tracks. I wouldn't bother though. If your existing tracks are 44.1 at 16 bit, record the new vocals at 44.1 at 24 bit. The bit depth (to my ears) makes a bigger difference than a higher sample rate. Hope this helps.

RW

Feb 26, 2006 7:02 PM in response to mattdean

There are a few ways to look at this.

1) Regions in the arrange all play back at the session sample rate. Example: 44k session, 96k audio file in arrange=slower playback

2) Logic automatically converts output sample rate so you can record independent of CA devices. Example: You have a session recorded at 96k, your interface is not connected, Logic will load Built in Audio, Logic runs tyhe sessions at 96k and converts the SRate of the session to match the supported sample rate. So you can run sessions at unsupported sample rates, this rarely makes sense if you cannot capture your audio at session sample rate (if needed).

3) There are a few other options for handling this, such as EXS24, which automatically handles SRC.

4) When Importing Audio Files there is a song preference which you can en/disable to automatically convert SR upon import.

I think your friend may have referred to point #2 and it was interpreted as point #1...perhaps. Hope this clears things up. J

Feb 26, 2006 7:04 PM in response to mattdean

There are a few ways to look at this.

1) Regions in the arrange all play back at the session sample rate. Example: 44k session, 96k audio file in arrange=slower playback

2) Logic automatically converts output sample rate so you can record independent of CA devices. Example: You have a session recorded at 96k, your interface is not connected, Logic will load Built in Audio, Logic runs tyhe sessions at 96k and converts the SRate of the session to match the supported sample rate. So you can run sessions at unsupported sample rates, this rarely makes sense if you cannot capture your audio at session sample rate (if needed).

3) There are a few other options for handling this, such as EXS24, which automatically handles SRC.

4) When Importing Audio Files there is a song preference which you can en/disable to automatically convert SR upon import.

I think your friend may have referred to point #2 and it was interpreted as point #1...perhaps. Hope this clears things up. J

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Different sample rates in same song - can Logic do it?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.