6 Replies Latest reply: May 3, 2012 10:28 AM by Jack E. Tilley
Jack E. Tilley Level 1 (5 points)

I have a recent purchase, an iBook w/ an internal optical drive. I inserted a dvd and now can't remove it. I'm sure there's a physical problem. I have tried all the tips, etc. It 'tries' to eject the DVD but can't. I noticed when I inserted the disk that it seemed 'not normal', i.e. a little more noise then I expected. This is the first time I have tried the drive. Any suggestions will be appreciated! Thanks,

 

Jack


iBook, Mac OS X (10.5.8)
  • Ronda Wilson Level 8 (41,210 points)

    All iBooks have an internal optical drive.

     

    Is it a slot-loading drive or tray-loading drive?

     

    (Slot-loading, I would guess if it truly has Mac OS X 10.5.8 installed.)

     

    When someone says they've "tried everything," yet come here for help, we need a list of the things they've tried, otherwise how can we know which "tip or trick" they may not know about?

     

    Sometimes a disc will eject if you shut down the iBook and hold down the trackpad button during startup. Is this one of those things you've tried?

  • Jack E. Tilley Level 1 (5 points)

    Hi Ronda.., Thanks for the reply... Yes, slot loading & 10.5.8. I have tried holding the trackpad as the iBook starts up.... I've tried using every method that I have learned in the past 30 years as a Mac fan....As I said, the unit tries to eject (makes noise, seems to start to eject then retracts). It doesn't come out far enough to see it or "grab it". I have THREE of these, trying to get one good one. One lost the system and won't accept the system re-install...seems to me the HD has went south, one has problems w/ the optical not working at all, & this one. Makes an old farmer (we have corn here in Ohio, too) frustrated. I'm reasonably sure it's a mechanical problem. I've taken the other two apart and I'm looking at this one too BUT....even after getting the drive out, I don't know how to get the disk out of the drive! Thanks again...... Jack

  • bund Level 3 (795 points)

    Put two (or three, depending on thickness) business cards on top of each other. When you power up the computer and the drive starts to spin, push them in and force the spinning DVD to stop. The DVD will eject right away.

  • Ronda Wilson Level 8 (41,210 points)

    As I said, unless you tell us "every method" that you have used, we can't know what to tell you that you may not have used.

     

    Here are a couple of other methods using Terminal:

    There are two commands that can be used in the Terminal (located in Applications/Utilities) which can be used to force disk ejection:

    The first command to try is drutil tray eject. Simply type in this command and press return.

    The other method takes a little more work but can work in instances where the first method fails.

    1. Type the command drutil list into the Terminal and press return . This will provide a list of all currently connected removable devices. [ScreenShot 1-DiskEject] -- connect FireWire/USB drives for this
    2. Use the command drutil tray eject 1

    In the above command, the number "1" should be replaced with whatever drive number you obtained in the first step.

    These are directly from cnet.com:

     

    http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13727_7-10333570-263.html

     

    There are other methods listed there, too, which you may have already tried, but may work if you haven't yet tried them.

     

    Good luck.

  • Ronda Wilson Level 8 (41,210 points)

    I have also read to use some double sided sticky tape, taped to a flat, thin card and try to grab the disc that way.

     

    Others have suggested holding the iBook on its side as you attempt to eject.

  • Jack E. Tilley Level 1 (5 points)

    Thanks for all the great tips!!! I will let everyone know my results!

    Jack