Pages layout mode how do I keep the frame from changing?

I've set up a page that includes several pictures for a yearbook. I have 6 pictures across and 5 rows. I'm using one of the frame styles. Pictures 2-6 in the row show the frame, but the first picture just shows the rectangular shape when I have it positioned where I want it. If I click on it and use the right arrow key to move it to the right 3 clicks, it then shows the desired frame shape. But, if I move it from that position back to the left, the first left arrow click it turns back into a rectangle. The same thing is occuring on each of the rows.

I'm not on the same computer right now so not certain of the version, but the frame I was using was the one in the middle of the 3rd row. I tried several different frames, the one with the push pin, photo corners, etc. and the others all seemed to work that I tried, but they weren't the ones I wanted. I'm using page layout mode using a row of pictures, followed by a row of names, with this repeating to fill the page.