Klaus1 wrote:
There is no real alternative to iDVD.
Ziatron wrote:
There is NO (good) alternative. But iDVD is very easy to get.
IDVD is a wonderful piece of software and well worth the low cost of $43.
http://www.amazon.com/Apple-MC623Z-A-iLife-VERSION/dp/B003XKRZES/ref=sr_1_1?ie=U
Do you say this, because it has the best quality? Does it have the best encoder of all authoring apps?
My iDVD-5 does always choose PCM for audio (although I would prefer AC3). iDVD doesn't offer much influence by the user other as graphical&menue stuff. But it does everything without the user having to think about what format and codec to pick and what the standards for DVD-confomity are.
BURN, I just today learned, that it has the ability. It is as "don't anoy the user, let me pick all decisions" as iDVD. It just encodes the source file you throw at it to DVD standard and burns it (including the TS folders, etc., just like iDVD, but without fancy menues etc.)
Toast, is very easy, too. You have to choose "DVD" from the media types (where there is: data disc, audio disc, image, copy).
Then you have "automatic" checked or pull out the options menue and set the bitrate etc. as wanted (more to decide, but not as much as it might sound, right now). One can set/pick the menue picture, too. You just drag any source file on it and Toast encodes it and you have the ready DVD with the TS folders etc.
Would be nice if there was a fourth way: use an encoding tool like Avidemux (has a auto-DVD option, too) to have the newest encoder available. Then use the resulting file to author a DVD (creeate the TS folders, menue etc.). That is what I am missing.
I wonder, what of the 3 has the best encoder: iDVD7 is the last version, so is certainly not the newest possible, Toast is always available in a sort of recent encoder. Burn? I don't know where it gets its encoders from, does it take the freeware encoders made by the ffmpegX and libravcodec projects that Handbrake and Avidemux use?