3 Replies Latest reply: Jun 2, 2012 8:52 PM by old comm guy
Igor_G5 Level 2 Level 2 (300 points)

My PowerBook G4 has a fn key in the lower left corner of my keyboard. Some of the keys have a second or third marking on them which is triggered by use of this key. What they have is confusing though. The J, K and L keys have 1, 2 and 3 respectively, the U, I and O keys Have 4, 5 and 6 respectively and most confusingly the 7, 8 and 9 keys have 7, 8 and 9 respectively. The M key has 0. The - key has = which is the next key over and only requires one key. The ; key has - and again confusingly the . key has. The / key has+. I'm not sure if I missed any but noe of these make any sense to me. I would rather not have the fn key and have a ctrl key on the right side of the space bar. Come to think of it I noticed that I have an enter key next to the43 right side command key which seems th do the same thing as the return key. I'd rather have command, option and control on both sides of the space bar. Can anybody explain this insanity to me?

  • old comm guy Level 4 Level 4 (2,235 points)

    OK, first off, the numbered keys and math operation keys you point out are activated as sort of a numerical keypad when you hit the F6 "Num Lock" key (actually, that key toggles the functionality).  I wouldn't guess this to have been a frequently-used feature. judging by the availability of USB external numeric keypads, which would have been a more acceptable solution to anyone doing serious numeric entry on a PowerBook.

     

    The "fn" key only modifies a few keys, like the arrow keys to give you the indicated functions, which would correspond to the home, end, and page up/down keys, plus a "clear" function on (I think) the 6 key.

     

    The "enter" key has subtle differences in some applications, like for instance Excel.

     

    Generally, the design issue is the significantly smaller allocated real estate for the keyboard, which required some editing of the normal Apple keyboard configuration.

  • Igor_G5 Level 2 Level 2 (300 points)

    I see. And now that I've taken a little while to try it out I get the full sense of what a truly stupid idea it is. And the num lock appears to lock out the entire keyboard other than the keypad. I don't know how anybody could get used to it. Personally I bought a USB keypad for my 17".

  • old comm guy Level 4 Level 4 (2,235 points)

    Igor_G5 wrote:

     

    I see. And now that I've taken a little while to try it out I get the full sense of what a truly stupid idea it is. And the num lock appears to lock out the entire keyboard other than the keypad. I don't know how anybody could get used to it. Personally I bought a USB keypad for my 17".

     

    I tried it a couple of times just for grins in the first month I had the TiBook.  I thought it was a pretty lame concept and fortunately never had to do a lot of numeric entry on the book, so it wasn't an actual issue.  If I had actually been doing any of that with the TiBook, I would have picked up the fast-selling USB numeric keypad for sure or just hooked up a normal keyboard when I was doing that kind of thing.

     

    BTW, I have replied once or twice to folks who accidentally hit the F6 key and then thought that their keyboard had gone berserk.  That was the real problem with the scheme, IMHO.