Dear All,
I had posted once in this thread, so I got an email about the new message tonight. I have created this software. And since 2010 I maintain my own topic right there, right on the Apple Support Communities web site. By the way, there actually IS the large happy user community - my topic has been viewed 310,000 times, and got 865 replies so far.
In this post I am going to argue that:
- The recent post by a user Mauonline is the false information;
- The user Mauonline is, as a minimum not a computer scientist (like he claims).
OK, I have found one true statement in that post. Like Mr. Mauonline had correctly indicated, there is no negative feedback about the driver. It's natural, as the driver is very stable and is packed with rich multitouch support. Just for reference, here is what you get by installing the recent version on a Macbook Retina / Pro / Air running Windows 8.1 via Boot Camp:
1.) Windows 8.1 edge-gestures;
2.) 2-finger pinch (action: zoom in/out);
3.) 3-finger dragging (action: OS X-like dragging);
4.) Horizontal 4-finger swiping (action: back / forward);
5.) Vertical 4-finger swiping (action: minimize/restore open windows);
6.) 4-finger tap (action: middle mouse button emulation).
Another improvements over Boot Camp 5.x drivers:
- User-customizable option to ignore the accidental trackpad input when typing;
- Accelerated/natural scrolling model implemented;
- Better pointer ballistics (i.e. how a pointer speed depends on a finger speed; six optimal presets built-in).
Now, I would like to argue that Mr.Mauonline is not a computer scientist (like he claims). The computer scientist shall be aware that OpenCandy, as 'detected' by only 1 out of 48 AV engines of VirisTotal, is nothing to hide, nothing to be afraid of. In fact, some of the most trusted antivirus and antispyware makers use it during the installation. And many world-wide popular programs do. Winamp, WinSCP are the first examples I can remember. Right in the PPA installer window, OpenCandy displays a small ad which is the recommendation to install some (clean) software. You can agree or decline. You are not forced to install anything unless you agree. And, please let me emphasize, OpenCandy shows up only within the installer, and only once. By the way I can agree that it's always a good idea to check the files you download with www.virustotal.com web site. They have all the antivirus engines put altogether for a quick online check. I just re-verified and 47 of 48 AV engines detect nothing. 1 of 48 detect OpenCandy, and it's true. This is in fact directly indicated in the EULA of PPA. And 0 of 48 find anything in the driver - so where is the infection?
Finally, the so called computer scientist claims that driver not approved by Microsoft automatically assumes rootkit / infection / makes system vulnerable / etc. But isn't the mandatory driver signing requirement a feature of 64-bit Windows only? Then 32-bit Windows is completely vulnerable by design?
I suspect Apple has become worried that, with the proper driver, the Windows experience on a Macbook gets absolutely competitive to OS X, and thus Apple hired an agent who has the task of spreading the false word, to not let the people really enjoy Windows on the Mac. Because this could affect the AppStore business, which in fact generates almost the same income for Apple as the sales of Macbook hardware.
Nevertheless I (of course) do not force anybody to even try the driver. I leave it up to every lady and gentleman on this forum, to judge and make the proper decision.