topcop1 wrote:
. . .
It was originally connected through an Airport Extreme and worked fine until recently.
Aha! That explains it.
I hate to have to tell you this, but backing-up that way is unreliable and not supported by Apple. See: Using Time Machine with an Airport Extreme Air Disk. The backups may have been damaged at some time while you were backing-up that way.
Time Machine stores your backups differently when they're done over a network. It puts them in a rather odd container called a sparse bundle disk image, rather than at the top level of the drive as it does when backup are made locally.
If you then connect that directly to your Mac, Time Machine will continue backing-up to it, but some other things won't find it, since they're not looking for a sparse bundle. In those cases, you must manually "mount" the sparse bundle by double-clicking it in a Finder window. See the blue box in Time Machine - Frequently Asked Question #17.
So, I guess it is time to buy a new, and larger external drive.
Maybe. How large, and how old, is it?
It varies widely (see Time Machine - Frequently Asked Question #1), but a "rule of thumb" is, TM needs 2-3 times the space as the data it's backing-up. And has a 3-year waranty.
If your drive is more than about 3 years old, it may be a good idea to get a new one anyway. They don't last forever.
If you want to keep it, your best bet may be to erase it with Disk Utility and let Time Machine start fresh, backing-up to it directly.
Any suggestions for that purchase?
OWC has a good reputation, both for hardware and support.
I recently got one of their Mercury Elite drives: http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/firewire/1394/USB/EliteAL/eSATA_FW800_FW400_USB, as have a number of other users, with good results.
You can also buy enclosures and drives from them separately.
But any decent-quality drive will work well.
A much more convenient alternative would be an Apple Time Capsule. It's more expensive, since it also includes a wireless router (like your Airport Extreme), but was designed for wireless Time Machine backups.