Wrong reply-to address sent on a reply

you can still change the reply with in multiple areas of mail, in mail preferences>composing

set how mail deals with email addresses when you respond to an email

This specific settings changes depending on which email account the email was sent to.

The other way is, when composing a letter, you can select your email address in the "From" field and choose a different email addres.

look for this...

Then you should do what TheSmokeMonster suggested. Cause I really dont understand your dilema then.

http://www.apple.com/feedback/macosx.html

Send your findings to apple about your user experience.

What he wants to do is Spoof his emails. Shame on him.

Carlo,

That's NOT the case at all. I am in the same situation. I have multiple e-mail addresses -- and multiple computers. In order to sync my e-mails, I have a rule that moves all the e-mails I receive into the iCloud account.

It used to be the case -- pre-ML -- that when replying to an e-mail, the response would be sent from the address to which the original e-mail was sent. Now, in ML, the response is automatically -- by default -- sent from the iCloud account and not the original address that received the e-mail.

Does that make sense?

It has NOTHING to do with spoofing. It's about organizing and responding with the right e-mail account.

T.

i have the same problem. my emails go to certain folders on my mac. when i click reply it goes uses another email address and i always forget to change it so i send the same messages from different addresses. it only happened after i upgraded to mountain lion. i wish i hadn't if i knew this would happen. do we have a solution?

I have the same issue and it is extremely infuriating. I did not upgrade to ML and this still randomly happened, although I cannot pinpoint when. And I have made it a point to make sure the correct email address is listed in the from box and mail still selects to send my message from whichever of my 7 email address it wishes. I've resorted to logging into each gmail account directly, annoying.

I recently upgraded to Mountain Lion and am having the same problem. Does anyone know if it's been fixed by Apple yet?

apple mail is completely broken.

Even after choosing to reply from another email address on a reply to absolutely make sure I reply from the address the email was sent to. Have in mind now, I can see now I am replying from the address I want.

It still sends from the wrong address......................

good job apple, your no google

I have submitted a case to Mountain Lion support, which was able to duplicate the problem on its own systems. No promises yet as to when or if this bug will be fixed.

This is not evidence of Mac mail being completely broken. This is a bug . . . hopefully one that Apple will fix shortly.

P.S. "your" should be "you're".

Same here. It is a pain....

Hope this is fixed soon.