A bit more hunting around coughed up the information that you can at least change the default account to send from.
Go to Mail > Preferences > Composing
Under "Addressing" click on the pop-up menu and select the account you want to be your default sending account for new mail.
No answer on the changing account order, but for me this solves my problem - hopefully it will be useful to you.
One problem: After you get the order nicely set like that, if at any time you go into Preferences > Accounts and edit or add any accounts, the order gets reset to:
- iCloud accounts
- Exchange accounts
- Alphabetical IMAP and POP accounts
...so you have to re-do the order in the Mailbox list, and sometimes quit and restart Mail in order for the change to be reflected in the From: dropdown list of accounts in a new email.
Not the end of the world, but it would sure be nice if Apple let you control the order in the Preferences > Accounts area and fixed this reset order issue.
The Issue that R Allen described is a frustrating one. It is one that didn't exist in Lion, but does in Mountain Lion. -
- arrange your mail accounts in the order you prefer in the Mail window
- this stays as your default order – unless you make changes to Preferences > Accounts
- when changes are made, it reverts to the order that R Allen described
- then, you have to manually rearrange your accounts again
This is something that did not occur in Lion, so is a newly introduced bug to Mountain Lion.
It would be great if they could fix it!
I have this issue too.
Rearranging within the mail interface is OK… but they have removes the 'expected behaviour' from preferences - for no good reason (and that part of the UI was designed to work that way, sothey are breaking their own UI rules by negating the functionality).
The mailboxes do seem to rearrange them - especially with the iCloud account as the first one. I haven't yet established what instigates this change. Is it related to iCLoud itself and incorrectly synchronising the wrong data (as it often does because you can no longer set the flow direction??!!!)
I think this is one of those dull 'auto features' introduced in Lion/ML that are supposed to help, but actually interfere with any creative or work process on your Mac, because you can no longer work naturally, or because like this, the settings need constant nannying to fix them.
Ditto here. As someone who owns multiple companies, plus Admins a non-profit, I have 20 email accounts...
..that are all in the wrong order now, thanks to ML.
Only solution I could come up with was to add numbers to the Description fields in the Preferences > Accounts list. Example:
Old names = AU-Susan, AU-Inbox, AU-Accounting (in their old, preferred, non-alphabetical order)
New names = 1. AU-Susan 2. AU-Inbox AU-Accounting
Annoying as ****, since it lengthens the account name, making it necessary to resize the column (which, on a MacBook Air means gobbling up valuable screen space). But at least it puts the accounts in the order I want them.
I too was using the 1.2 3 numbering method for each account. I found a simple solution. In your mail default page, go to the inbox or wherever all the mail boxes of each account are. Change the sequence there and the sequence changes automatically in the composing drop down.
Cheers. If someone has posted this solution. My apologies.
This problem seems to have carried over to Yosemite too. I can render my dozen or so Mailboxes in the Inbox list, but as soon as I open Preferences > Accounts and make a change, I have to re-order them again.
Short of adding 01, 02, etc to the names, there doesn't seem to be a way to reorder them in Preferences so they stick.