You could always take a screen shot of the window (hold down command-shift-4 and then when the cursor changes to a plus either drag a rectangle around the list or hit spacebar and when it changes to a camera then click on the Reminders window).
That will put a screen shot on your desktop. Then open it in Preview and you can print it. Mine came out 90 degrees rotated left so I hit command-R to rotate it to the right orientation.
This seems a bit more work than it should be, for sure
Wow! I just spent 20 minutes trying to figure out how I did it last night. I knew I wasn't crazy because I really did do this. I'm getting the same results you are.
BUT……I finally figured it out!!!!
Do not click on a word. Instead, click on the double red line that is between the check box and the first word of any of the items in your reminders list. When you do, the entire line will change to a gray color (indicating that it is highlighted. NOW, hit Command+A to select all.
Command+C will copy the text.
Go to Pages
Command+P will paste it into your document.
YES!!! I got it. Sorry for not getting it right the first time.
FYI - in your Reminders list, all your items will be "highlighted" gray. To get that to go away you will have to click onto a different list and then go back to your original one and they will be unselected.
Let me know if this works for you.