Acoustic Guitar to GarageBand 3

Hi,
I'm interested in recording my acoustic guitar (finger picking style) onto GarageBand 3. I'd also like to record melody lines over it with an electric guitar and harmonica. Right now I have a midi setup (a Marshall JMP-1 preamp and Boss RSP550 Stereo Signal processor). I'm considering selling it, though, to get some $ for a beautiful acoustic guitar amp (Schertler "David"). That would leave me with my faithful Mesa Boogie Mark IIB, the new acoustic amp (no midi on either), and a lot of great stomp boxes.
I have a few questions that I'd really appreciate some assistance on:
1) Do I need that midi set up to interface with GarageBand?
2) Can I use the Boogie and effects pedals, instead, for the electric and still interface with GarageBand?
3) Can I get the acoustic into GarageBand using a mic?
4) Basically: What do I need to get those instruments into the GarageBand "domain"?
5) It would be a super bonus to have the guitar (acoustic esp.) transcribed into written notes like you can, now, using the provided computer keyboard. I can write it down...but the finger picking is complex and, sorry to say...but I'm lazy about it. Can I do that using some kind of electronic converter that I run the acoustic through?
This is a great resource, people. Thanks for your time.
Bob

iMac G4 Mac OS X (10.4.3)

iMac G4, Mac OS X (10.4.3)

Posted on Apr 1, 2006 9:02 PM

Reply
8 replies

Apr 1, 2006 9:20 PM in response to guitar

Hi guitar,

1) You don't need a MIDI-only interface. You can buy a relatively cheap interface that has XLR & TRS inputs (Mic cable and 1/4' cable) too.

2) If your amp has a line out (important that it's called LINE out, not headphone) you can plug direct into the computer. But the interface route is better. If your amp doesn't have the line out, you can always use the interface and a decent mic to record the amp (alot of pros prefer the sound of an amp being miced to get the 'room' sound).

3) Yes. If your acoustic has an electric pre-amp, you could use that plugged into the interface too.

4) Plug in the interface (making sure you have all the drivers needed), plug in the instrument, select the input on the track, and hit record (reader's digest version of instructions).

5) Sorry no transcription of "real" instruments.

Good Luck!

-xs4is

Apr 2, 2006 10:07 AM in response to xs4is

Thanks for the info, xs4is.
Just to be sure:
1) You're saying that I don't need to hold onto my Marshall midi rig? That would be great. I really want this new acoustic amp for performing solo and chamber music.
2) My amp has a "Slave" port which is the line out to either a mixing board or another speaker. But it sounds like the interface is the way to go. And I like the sound of a mic best, too.
3) Any suggestions for where I can get the interface/drivers and what I'd ask for with each one?
4) Bummer about the transcription. Oh well...I need to stay on top of my writing skills, anyway.
Thanks again.
Bob
PS: How come I'm getting so many "Apple Discussions form GarageBand..." replies in my mail? You're reply's been great...but, as far as I've been able to tell, the others are regarding other posts. I'm relatively new to this process and not sure what's up with that.

Apr 2, 2006 12:04 PM in response to guitar

Hello again guitar,

1) I'm not familiar with the Marshall that you have, but if it is MIDI only, then your better option is to get a decent interface.

2) If the slave line on your amp is a true "line-out" you could plug it directly into ouyr computer. But you need to make sure that it is a true line-in. Impedence issues could damage both your computer and your amp. And the interface will still give you better audio quality.

3) Musiciansfriend.com samash.com music123.com are some online sites, but you could do some price checking on all of them, go to a local store and see if they can price match. 9 times out of 10 they will. You need to ask yourself what you need form your interface. How many inputs/outputs, if you need just a gain knob or more complex controls, you know little things like that. And with GB you will want an interface with a lineout to monitor with (or at least a headphone jack) because GB doesn't work well when you have to split the input and output signals between devices. I would suggest googling presonus, m-audio, motu...stay away from Digidesign stuff like the MBox. Alot of people are having alot of issues with Digi products right now. The drivers will be provided with the interface or on line at their websites.

4) If you need transcription really bad, check out a program called Finale. I don't use it, but alot of people do. You could also upgrade your audio program to Logic. It has a really good transcription function, and is a much more superior DAW than GB is.


PS.
I've never gotten emails from the discussion board...are you subscribing to a bunch of threads?

Good Luck Guitar!

Apr 3, 2006 10:31 PM in response to xs4is

Sorry to interrupt, but I have a similar question. I just made the switch to Mac and have started using GB3. I also am recording with an acoustic guitar. I have been plugging it in directly to the computer. I am extremely ingorant when it comes to recording and what equipment to purchase. Based on your comments to 'guitar' I need some sort of interface? I have seen a couple of by M-Audio. Is this the way to go? I only plan on recording one thing at a time so I don't need anything too advanced I assume. Please help! Thanks.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Acoustic Guitar to GarageBand 3

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.