Hi there,
Thanks for your post.
Here is what I think you are saying:
Google is better than iCloud = Solution for Searching Contacts via Spotlight!
Here is my thinking:
One of the Biggest Reasons I don't want to add Google to my Cloud Echosystem is SUPPORT! No matter how good or bad someone's experience is with AppleCare, it's still a lot better, for most people, than not having anyone to talk to! AppleCare, in USA at least, is a Toll Free Phone Call. The Customers are not being charged by the minute! Add to that Apple Stores. Google has nothing like that, except their own Discussions Boards like we have here at Apple!
If in the end this issue - SPOTLIGHT STOPS SEARCHING CONTACTS - turns out to be caused by iCloud interactions with our Macs, and thus Spotlight Search, then Apple should fix it! Hopefully they are working on it already!
In my previous Post I tried to provide as many specifics as possible about my OS, Hardware, and my Test Steps! That way there is a better Contextual Reference! But not all Comments on this topic, and in general on Apple Discussions Pages provide that kind of Specifics, Details, Context! Therefore, even if Apple reads All Our Comments All The Time, they have to work even harder trying to help us. In theory, they could cross reference our Info to see what was the latest Apple hardware that we have registered, assuming everybody registers their purchases:)! So...
It'd be great if All Comments included: OS Version, Hardware Description, and Specific Step when Testing an Issue…
If everyone who not only posted here, but also read this particular Discussion, provided Specifics, then Apple would be in a better position to see if there is some kind of a Common Pattern. But that assumes that Apple reads this Discussions! I hope they do!
After I'll speak to them about this issue, and they hopefully help me fix it, I will try post about about that fix here. But that might not be a solution for all users, because we all don't use our Macs the same way. Some OS Installers are specific to some Hardware. But regardless, Spotlight is a Core Universal Feature that should work for all users all the time!
Another reason why I suspect that this issue is connected to iCloud is this…
On my iPhone and iPad, I have Podcast App. Even if I Disable Automatic Downloads of Podcasts, that App is often, if not always, polling iCloud, as if it's saying:
"Hello, iCloud, do you have any new stuff for the Subscriptions on this device! If yes, I need to let this device' owner know about it, so that he/she can Download any of that Manually, if they want!!! I'll be back soon so that we can go through this List of Ours together again. That's my job, Thanks.. :)!"
Same thing, I suspect is happening to our iCloud related stuff on our Macs - Contacts, Notes, Calendars etc.. All those Apps constantly communicate with iCloud! So, if anything is less then perfect between iCloud and our Mac, the Spotlight might be affected!!! That is why this Issue comes and goes, at least for me!
When I Edit, and thus Refresh, Update, a Contact on my Mac, that Updated Info is sent to iCloud, and Spotlight is also Notified about that Specific Contact to be included in the Search Results!!! But obviously such "Refreshment" of the Contacts is not happening automatically all the time, and that is my guess why Spotlight FORGETS about All our Contacts, and thus Spotlight simply doesn't SEE them…