I’ve read through this entire discussion thread and I think I’ve spent about as much time as Pete Boston with this infuriating problem. However I’ve gone about this a little differently than anyone else, so perhaps this information may be useful...
Bought two iPhone 5’s to replace iPhone 4’s. AT&T is our carrier. Our home is in Marin County north of San Francisco. Work is downtown San Francisco. No problem with getting good LTE in San Francisco for new iPhone 5. At home is a different story. According to AT&T we are just beyond the LTE service area. (There are 3 towers in our area but only one has LTE.) But instead of locking on to the previous strong 3G service we had with our old iPhone 4, the new 5 phone fluctuates between “No Service” and 5 bars - constantly! Unfortunately 20% of the time we have no phone connection! And since it can’t lock into a signal, it just drains the battery.
I have called AT&T’s technical help 3 times and have gone into the store twice. (At least I’ve been credited some money for poor service.) I’ve been to the Apple Store and have opened a case file with Apple for both phones.
But here’s my different approach - my husband and I also opened a new account at Verizon and got Verizon phones and are testing them side by side our old AT&T phones. Pete, I realize you and others have posted on this discussion thread Verizon problems, but here’s my experience:
There are those of us who are experiencing both software and carrier issues. Previous good experience with service providers did not prepare us for our providers issues with LTE. True LTE is not available in all areas and many carriers are still testing their equipment so it is not reliable. It seems many of us are not able to lock into a strong LTE signal.
There seems to be an Apple software issue as well. Both Pete Boston and Megapantallica have correctly determined that the phone wants to lock onto LTE or nothing. When the signal is weak or fluctuates, the phone won’t lock onto a stronger lower signal. Once it does, the phone also won’t seamlessly lock onto a new signal when the phone has changed location.
In summary - It pays to do your 4G LTE research on all the carriers in your area! Find out from your friends, co-works, or neighbors if they use 4G LTE before you upgrade to iPhone 5.
I can tell you that replacing the sim cards in both our AT&T phones did not change our service issues and we still experienced “No Service” 20% of the time.
So, crazy as we are, but incredibly frustrated with our AT&T situation, we went out and got another set of iPhones and opened a Verizon account. I realize we are lucky to be able to do this, so I am reporting my findings.
We have been testing the one set of AT&T phones side-by-side the Verizon set. Both phones have no problem locking on to our home wi-fi. In our home location. The Verizon phones seem to work at home unlike AT&T. We seem to have a strong LTE signal. No problem with signal hunting. We went out to the rural part of the county this weekend and the phone had no problem changing from LTE to 3G.
In the meantime, we have found a fix for our “No Service” problem at home with our AT&T phones by turning off “Enable LTE”.
With time running out to return one set of phones, we have to make a decision. We have been with AT&T for 15 years and have a good cell phone plan with cheaper data. But remembering to manually turn off LTE at home until our local towers are upgraded to LTE is a real bummer. This is a real clunky solution. However, my husband who works in IT hates to give up the ability to use the web while on a phone call which he can do on AT&T but not Verizon.
Or we go to Verizon and pay more for a shared data plan. For our home and work locations this carrier seems to work much better. And even more compelling, I ran a speed test over the weekend and got a ping of 25ms, and a shocking 51.2 Mbps download!! It was an anomaly but we can easily get 27+ Mbps download speed and almost the same upload on the LTE connection.
Good luck everyone! I’m exhausted by this problem.
Everyone who reads this discussion experiencing problems - please report case files to Apple and to your carrier. Let's get this problem fixed!