** iPhone 5 Verizon Wireless (VZW) - NYC Trip Report **
Summary: iPhone 5 VZW did not work well in most NYC locations. Results are not significantly different than Metro-Boston results when not right near a cell tower [referring to cell tower as 4-5 bar signal strength areas]
I would still like assistance from someone who has access to both an iPhone 5 on VZW and Android phone to do testing in NYC/Metro Boston and prove whether these issues are all VZW, all iPhone 5, or a combination of both. EIther way, the combination is unacceptable, and neither Apple nor VZW is taking ownership of resolving this poor experience.
Since I do not own a VZW LTE phone, still not clear whether this is a VZW or Apple iPhone problem (or both). Perhaps I just believe VZW's marketing way too much to believe their network is really this horrible vs. AT&T in both Metro Boston and NYC, so I'm going to hold out hope that the iPhone 5 has some responsibility in this miserable experience.
I was able to perform a head-to-head test in one poor performing location with an AT&T iPhone 5 vs. a Verizon iPhone 5 and the AT&T iPhone 5 was able to pull 13.5Mb/s (comparable to GS III) while the VZW iPhone 5 was only able to transfer at 1.4Mb/s.
Slow and unreliable iPhone 5 VZW LTE coverage throughout the West Side of NYC (and one location on the East Side [I only was at one location]).
Was able to compare to AT&T Galaxy S III in almost all low-strength locations and in those locations, AT&T transfer rates were significant greater, in some cases the results were this significant -- 40Mb+ (ATT) vs. 0.3Mb+ (VZW). I did witness some decent VZW performance in a few high-strength areas, but even in those areas, AT&T was as good, if not better.
Testing was performed in at least 2 dozen locations throughout NYC, inc. locations like Time Sq. and 34th St and neighborhoods primarily on West Side, but also East Side not near big tourist attractions. Testing was primarily performed outdoors at street level.
Also performed a test at the Fairfield, CT Welcome Center (I95 North), AT&T GS III (48Mb/s) VZW iPhone 5 (0.3Mb/s). VZW low signal strength -107dBm. There was a strong signal location in CT where VZW was able to pull down 25Mb/s (didn't write down the location), but even there, AT&T was pulling down 40Mb+.
In Charlton, MA (Mass Pike East), VZW had strong signal and -81 dBM and was able to provide transfer rates of 9Mb/s on iPhone 5. Wasn't able to perform ATT testing at this location since battery was dead.
In one location i was able to confirm strong 3G signal (~-55dBM / actual number in thread above), yet LTE signal strength and transfer rates were poor. I have not have a problem with low 3G signal strength on the iPhone 5, the signal strength problem seems very specific to the LTE signal.
I would love to hear from VZW iPhone 5 and non-iPhone 5 (Android LTE) users in Metro Boston and NYC to see how your experience is and if you're seeing different results than I do. (Significantly better results from other iPhone 5 VZW users could point to phone HW, even though both the phone HW and SIM have been swapped), same results from non-iPhone 5 Android LTE users would point to iPhone, same results from everyone would point to the VZW network failing to meet advertised expectations.