Over a year ago, Apple came out with the really absurd Music Player for the iPad. I hated that player so much (for so many reasons) that I gave up listening to music and podcasts on the iPad, instead listening to them exclusively on my iPhone. I hated that Music Player that came with iOS 5. I complained about it on this board and complained to Apple. (My biggest complaint - that PDF files that podcasters occasionally drop in their feeds got "stuck" in the Music Player, didn't get "resolved" until iOS 6 when they came out with the steaming pile known as the "Podcasts" app. Don't even get me started on that one.)
Anyway, I decided to load some songs onto the new 4th Gen iPad I got and went to go play them on the iPad when I had a sudden revelation - the "new" iTunes 11 is made to look and act EXACTLY like the crappy music player in the iPad. Look at the iTunes 11 out of the box - without the left-hand menu bar, it looks and acts exactly like the crappy iPad music player that I've hated for over a year.
Now, there are some things that make sense on the iPad player. For example, I'm not really building playlists; I do that on the home computer. Nor am I managing devices like my iPhone or iPad. That's what I use the home computer for. But that's where I take a different appraoch to Apple. Instead of "dumbing down" the home interface to the lowest common denominator, why not build up the iPad version to be more like iTunes?
If you read the notes, Apple is all about trying to make the interfaces for iTunes as close to those used on their devices as possible. But that's not very efficient. I may have 500 songs on my iPhone or iPad, and that interface works very well for that (although I really wish they'd bring back the pre-iOS5 iPad Music Player). But at home, when I have 23,000 songs? That interface is not very effecient.
I used to be able to drag and drop artwork into iTunes. Even now, with the "Get Info" open, drag and drop no longer works for me, only copy and paste.
There are work arounds, yes. I could accomplish in 5 steps what it used to take me 1 step. But when you take 23,000 songs, that's now still 5 times the work.
After I freaked out about iTunes 11 and googled how to get the left hand bar back, I'm happy with everything except not being able to see the artwork for a selected item without playing it. I'm often listening to one song while working on the art for several others. Yes, there are lots of multiple views and I can toggle views and Get Info and all sorts of stuff to get to see the artwork. But what I don't get is the "Why?" part of it. Why not allow a separate window where I can see the artwork for the selected item? Is that so hard to do?
And why remove the left hand bar? I have about a hundred playlists, and it's easier to drag and drop to the playlists in the left hand menu than it is to try to use the "Add to Playlist >" pop-up menu. Why make the left hand menu off by default and make people go google how to turn it back on? I suspect because it is soon on its way out as well.
I'm just worried that with this trend, the left hand menu is the next to go. I want to see the selected art back. But what I *REALLY* want is to see no more disappearing features in iTunes 12.