I personally am a BIG fan of the 57 off axis, away from the speaker cone. As a guitarist, I have spent a lot of time over the years experimenting with mic placement, and that particular way of doing it ALWAYS works. So you're doing that much right, as far as I'm concerned.
A ribbon mic like a Royer 121 or 122, facing the speaker cone directly also yields impressive results. Especially with heavy distorted tones... it smooths it out in a very favorable way.
However, with a 4 X 12, or even a 2 X 12 cabinet, the single mic on the speaker only gets you part way there (although it's generally sufficient). I would suggest placing a condenser mic (like the Baby Blue) about 3 to 5 feet out in front of the cabinet(s), to capture more of the 4 (or 2) speakers working together.
If the space you're recording the amp in has a wood floor, that distant mic set close to the floor can be really cool. Loads of low end... too much really, but it's fun to hear!
Another cool thong about the close and distant mic, is that you can pan those two tracks away from each other, for a really wide tone, that is still a single performance, so it doesn't suffer from the "slop" of a doubled part (unless you;re going for that sound intentionally).