Apple Event: May 7th at 7 am PT

Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

2010 unibody 15" Macbook Pro 3 beeps after reformat

I bought a 2010 Unibody 15" Macbook Pro from an office that was closing. They had not removed their software from the Macbook and did not provide the username and password. I tried to reboot from a purchased copy of Mountain Lion and I just get to the gray apple with the spinning wheel and a repeating 3 beeps. So I booted it as a taget drive and hooked it up to my 2008 17" Macbook Pro and used Disk Utility to erase the hard drive. Then I used a purchased copy of Snow Leopard to reformat the drive. In the Target mode, it showed the installation was successful. But upon unmounting and restarting, the 15" Macbook Pro returns to the gray apple and spinning wheel and 3 beeps. Undaunted, I again started it in Target mode and hooked it back up to the 17" Macbook Pro. Again I used Disk Utility to Erase the 15" hard drive. Then I unmounted the 15" and put the Mountain Lion disk in and tried to boot the 15" from the CD. No joy! Again the gray apple, spinning wheel and the repating set of 3 beeps.


When I first got the 15 Macbook Pro, it would boot to the Username and Password screen so it looked like it had been used on a regular basis before it was sold.


Any ideas?

MacBook Pro, Mac OS X (10.0.x)

Posted on Jan 4, 2013 6:48 AM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on Jan 4, 2013 6:55 AM

The 3 beeps is usually a RAM issuse, wrong ram, bad ram, chips not seated correctly...

39 replies

Jan 4, 2013 12:32 PM in response to Wander65

Yes, that is a drive, I wish I could have helped you, and I am REALLY surprised OGELTHORPE was not able, as he is one of those guru types. I wish you all the best, I think when you erased the disk, you might have messed up the format. I had the unpleasant experience myself, and it is quite easy to do. I wish all the best, @ $350.00/gallon :)

Jan 5, 2013 3:11 AM in response to sanjampet

OK some more info. I actually have 2 15" Unibody Macbook Pros from 2010. Same source. Probably different original users but exhibiting the exact problems we have discussed. After the earlier discussions, I did the SMC reset on both and thenI set both up in Target mode and hooked each in turn up to my 2008 Macbook Pro 17" Pre-Unibody. Used Disk Utility to Erase and reformat each drive as Mac OS Extended (Journaled). On one, I was able to use ALT - D to initiate the Hardware test. It's now been running for about 3 hours but at least it's still running. The other MBP 15, I set in Target mode and used my retail copy of Snow Leopard in my MBP 17 to install the system on the 15. At the end of the install, the MBP 17 restarted using the MBP 15 as the startup disk. I used Dsik Utility to verify it and it checked out fine. I opened a couple of programs on it and everything runs nice and fast. I restarted with the hard drive for the MBP 17 as the startup disk and then used Disk Utility to unmount and eject the MBP 15. All of the following produce the same effect of the gray apple logo and the 3 beeps that loop contiuously:


Normal startup using the power button

Safe mode startup using the SHIFT key

AHT using the D key on startup

AHT using the ALT D keys on startup

AHT using the COMMAND D Keys on startup (read it on one of the forums)

SMC reset as descibed in Apple Support.


It will still boot in Target mode and I can still see that Snow Leopard is intact on the hard drive.

Jan 5, 2013 9:37 AM in response to Wander65

I have spent the bulk of the morning recreating what you have done with dissimilar but unsuccessful results.


I have a 2006 MBP with 3 partitions. I made that a Target Disk MBP and used my 2010 MBP as the source to install a retail Snow Leopard OS in an empty partition. The result was that some of the OS files were installed but not all. My 2010 MBP made the restart chime but was stuck on the Apple logo screen with the SL install disk inside. A PRAM reset was needed to unfreeze it and retrieve the disk. The 2006 MBP has Snow Leopard installed in another partition and Leopard in the third partition. Thus it is not a question of incompatible hardware.


Currently I am in the process partitioning the 2010 MBP in order to install the Snow Leopard retail disk OS just to make certain that it is functional.


My question to you is why did you choose to use Target Disk Mode to install the OS? Are the Optical Drives inoperable?


I'll respond later when I get the 2010 fully partitioned and see how the test install fares.


Ciao

Jan 5, 2013 12:16 PM in response to OGELTHORPE

You know, I'm starting to wonder if there is an issue with the Optical drives. But when I started to work on these, I was getting the 3 Beeps regardless of what I did. Target mode was/is the only way I could successfully access the drives. Before I used Target Mode to install SL on the one, I would just get the blinking folder/question mark. If I inserted th retail SL disc then the folder would change to the gray apple and I'd get the 3 beeps. So that would seem to suggest that the MBP 15 is at least recognizing that there is a DVD in the drive.


I'm not getting how you could have an operative OS on the Hard Drive and the computer won't recognize it's there.


Wish I had a couple new RAM chips I could swap in and seeif that changed anything.

Jan 5, 2013 3:37 PM in response to Wander65

What should be simple, turned out to be otherwise. After three failed attempts at partitioning, A PRAM reset allowed a new partition to be installed.


Inserted the retail SL disk and about 25 minutes into the install, hear the chime, get a Apple logo and it just sits there. Did that twice.


Inserted the original SL install disk and installed the OS, BUT got hung up on the welcome screen. Twice! PRAM reset, allowed the conclusion of the installation. OPTION key startup gives two bootable volumes.


Partitioned the new partition and inserted the retail SL disk to install on the now third partition and again the chime and the Apple logo (without the gear which showed up with the original install disk) and nothing else. I let it sit for 45 minutes in the naive hope that it would complete the process. Did not.


My conclusion is that there is something faulty with the retail disk. I may try a last Don Quixote attempt tomorrow and swap in a different HDD in the 2010 MBP and se if that makes any difference. I have doubts.


With all my efforts with the retail SL disk, I did get the same result, a partial file transfer. This was both via Target disk or a direct attempt. This suggests that Target disk might be a valid method, but not definitive in my eyes.


Have you tried swapping and switching the RAM chips among the two 2010 MBPs. Even one chip, if it is good should allow for operation. You said that one of the MBPs was running the Apple Hardware test. Any results?


Maybe the simplest option is to take the two MBPs to the Apple store on have the Genius bar technicians plug in their analytic tools and get a definitive diagnosis of the faults.


Ciao.

Jan 5, 2013 4:32 PM in response to OGELTHORPE

Ok a little more info. The MBP 15 with the erased hard drive responded to the Online AHT, ran for a few seconds and then displayed a little globe and triangle/exclamation mark symbol (attached) for the next several hours and never changed. That turned out to be trouble with connecting to the Internet wirelessly. I finally got it to connect correctly and it ran the initial test and found no problems. I ran the extended test and it found no problems.


The Optical drive is at least functioning. Prior to the Online AHT test, I put in a very old AHT CD (2001) and I got a message saying the AHT was not compatible with that computer.


Trying to boot from the SL DVD still gives the 3 beeps and gray apple. However, trying to boot from retail versions of 10.5.6 and 10.4.7 gives the following screen: User uploaded file


So at least we know the optical drive is working.


I'm going to do the RAM chip switch as you suggested and will report back. You may have something there with the suggestion of the Retail SL disk being corrupt in some way.


By the way, I got the partial instal results yesterday using the Target mode and a unibody 2010 MBP 17 as the host drive.

Jan 6, 2013 11:46 AM in response to Wander65

I took the RAM out of both MBP's. I put one 2 Gb chip in the one with the erased hard drive. It still gives me the blinking folder/question mark on regular startup. It will go into the online AHT and returns no negative results.


I put one 2Gb chip in the one with the with SL (loaded via Target Mode). Still get the 3 beeps on startup. Won't boot in safe mode. Won't go into the Online AHT. If I take all the RAM out and try to start it, I get just one beep which I'm thinking means it has no RAM.


So a trip to the Apple Store may be in store for the both of them.


Do you think a new copy of SL would be worth buying to try and install on the one with the erased hard drive?

Jan 6, 2013 12:30 PM in response to Wander65

Here is some more RAM/error code information for your reading pleasure:


http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2341


http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2674


Buying the retail Snow Leopard disk makes sense. It saves having to get the original Installation disks. Hold off on that until you get the diagnosis of the issues from the Apple store technicians.


I swapped HDDs in the 2010 MBP, partitioned it (no problems today) and installed the SL retail disk. Like yesterday, I heard the chime and then gray Apple screen with no gear. Conclusion, the disk must be faulty. Therefore I cannot recreate your scenario at the moment.


Unless one is in the Amazon, there comes a point where even a long trip to an Apple store is cost effective. I would make the appointment if I were in your situation.


Keep me posted as to what the technicians find.


Ciao.

Feb 15, 2013 12:23 PM in response to OGELTHORPE

Well, I have an early 2011 macbook pro that has had the exact same thing occur. I was getting 3 beeps upon moving my macbook pro ever so slightly ( i7 2635qm / 16gb ddr3 / Ati 256mb ddr5 graphics). I tested the macbook pro with my bottom cover off gently pressing on my dimm slots, memory, hard drive connectors... .everything. The laptop stayed running with zero issues ( Yes I was electrostatically shielded while testing via rubber gloves and a grounding strap to my wrist ).



As soon as I put the case back on, it immediatly started beeping. I then remembered seeing those HORRIBLE pogo pin grounding connectors around the ram slots. I decided to take some black electrical tape and cover over the spots on the bottom plate wher the pogo pins make contact not only around the memory, but all over the bottom plate including the grounding rod seen in this post here :


User uploaded file


http://6ixpassions.com/post/1095520847/fix-the-ticking-clicking-sound-in-your-ma cbook-pro



Guess what? I can now pick up my macbook pro, move it around, tap on the bottom, shake it, toss it on my bed, stuff it in a case and carry it around in my backpack.... and I have had ZERO issues since 😀


I hope this helps some of you guys having this annoying 3 beep issue. It may not be the MASTER fix for the issue, but it sure did resolve my problems. The only thing I can immagine is that there were are either faulty pogo pins causing grounding shorts ( Which is very common if you research the pogo pin connector type ), or a magical Genie flew into my macbook pro and stopped the issue LOL.

2010 unibody 15" Macbook Pro 3 beeps after reformat

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.