OK after 33 km of nighttime VTT (Vélo Tout Terrain or "Mountain Biking") in the Liège area last night I am now back to trying to understand and then set-up my home network!
Here's the latest and I guess I'm not confused, just not understanding the machinations of all this.
As a reminder, here is (was) my setup:
NOTE: Level-A is the basement, underground level where my MBP is located; Level-B is my living room ground floor where the ISP Modem with WiFi is located and Level-C is my upstairs where the eMac is located (ethernet cable runs to this eMac).
My setup is (*was):
- My Internet Service Provider (ISP) modem has an ethernet cable running from it to the WAN port of my Apple Extreme which is on Level-B
- I then have an ethernet cable going from a LAN port of the Apple Extreme to my MacBook Pro 13" (May 2010) on Level-Arunning Mountain Lion 10.8.2.
- I also have another ethernet cable going from another LAN port on the Apple Extreme to my eMac (Feb 2005 – no WiFi on this model) on Level-C running Mac OS 10.5.11 Leopard.
- My ISP's modem is also wireless and the network is called "SteveBelWiFi"
- I have *(had) setup a wireless WiFi Network on my Airport Extreme and called that "Steve Airport WiFi"
*I turned this Airport Extreme-created WiFi off and here is why:
Before installing the Airport Extreme, my ISP service generally gave me download speeds via ethernet of 28 mbps and upload speeds of 2.8 mbps which is super as far as I am concerned. But it is also what I am used to so it has become my standard. (Certainly files don't download at that speed- but I can download a large, 200 mb test file at constant 3.5 mbps speed repeatedly). WiFi speeds vary with distance to the ISP Modem B-box (as one would expect) but generally on Level-B or Level-C I can get speedtest.net speeds of 21 mbps download and 2.4 upload on average and I've done a hundred+ tests this week and others since March 2012. On Level-A the speeds vary more and are generally from 5 to 8 mbps download and 1.8 upload. These figures are similar on the iPad and on the MBP or PBG4 (when wireless of course). Note that in all cases PING is 23-29 but can be 90 for the Level-A wireless, but never over 100 UNLESS A PROBLEM!
And here is that problem:
When I had the setup as above (with the Airport Extreme "Steve Airport WiFi") then when I tried to use the "SteveBelWiFi" wireless network it was s-l--o---w and I mean PING of 300 to 600, with download of from 0.50 to 1.3 mbps (YES- a crawl!) and uploads of from 0.6 to 1.8 (slow, but OFTEN Faster than the downloads!!)
BUT when I unplugged the Ethernet cable from the ISP Modem running-down to the MBP on Level-A----- (of course the airport Network "Steve Airport WiFi" was immediately GONE as there was nothing feeding the Airport Extreme) -- Guess what-- IMMEDIATELY the ISP's "SteveBelWiFi" was back to the old high-speed. I did this "plug-in, test speed, unplug, test speed" 4 times in 2 minutes and each time it was the same: Nothing going to the Airport Extreme, ISP SteveBelWifi FAST -- 21-27 mbps downloads etc. BUT plugged-in going to the Extreme: instantly the test shows 1.0 (or slower!) downloads via SteveBelWiFi and about 1.1 upload speeds…
OK so I then went to Airport Utility and just turned-OFF the Airport Extreme WiFi: "Steve Airport WiFi" is now GONE. I am still plugged-in to the Airport extreme so I get ethernet internet to my MBP and my eMac-- but the only wireless in the house is via the ISP Wireless "SteveBelWiFi" but it is back to the FAST, historic speeds.
Probably I can just leave this as is since it connects my iPad on Level-B and Level-C just fine and that's my main use location for the iPad. Even on Level-A it's OK-- and my MBP is connected via the Airport Extreme but with an ethernet cable-- so it won't drop the signal like the past year prior to my Apple Extreme adventure when I just had it connected via WiFi "SteveBelWiFi". AND I can communicate wirelessly from my iPad to my MBP (example: Send print jobs via ecamm's "Printopia" to the MBP). So it is doing 98% of what I need even without an Apple Extreme wifi network. (The 2% is getting my Canon MP640 scanner via ethernet but think I'll conquer that with help from another post already!)
BUT---- But I would like to understand WHY this is happening. I mean WHY when I set-up a wireless network on my Airport Extreme does that effectively "destroy" my ISP's "SteveBelWiFi" wireless speed? (When I had the Airport Extreme "Steve Airport WiFi" set-up it was very fast-- but also as the Airport Extreme is in the basement (Level-A) it was slow or NOT possible to connect on Levels B and C. That was the primary motivator to purchase the Extreme just a week ago!
QUESTION: If I create a wireless network exactly as described by John in this post with the exact name "SteveBelWiFi" and have it on "automatic" will the speeds be FAST? Will the signal strength be Strong on all Levels (A, via the Extreme; and B&C via the ISP Modem)??? Or will I go back to slow slow slow when it connects to the Level-B ISP Modem???
I hope this is clear. Let me know if I should test anything / do anything or just be content with where I am at. (But a bit odd to have invested in this Airport Extreme and not be using it for wireless…)
Thanks!
Best regards,
Steve Schulte
Friday 11 January 2013