I have the newest iOS for the 4S. I've looked up this question before and all the answers say to sync the old phone to iTunes under Tones but there isn't a Tones option on iTunes anymore. Help..
Are you syncing to the same itunes?
Did you restore from a backup http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1766
Yes I am using the same iTunes. I backed up my old phone to my computer and restored the new from the back up. The only thing I did different was delete my pictures off my old phone before backing it up.
Retrieving data ...