Stopping the automatic download of a previously purchased album

Hi everyone, hopefully you can help.

Years ago i downloaded a terrible album that i deleted.

Now, whenever i log onto my account on iTunes it automatically re-downloads it.

I've been through Preference > Store - and unticked the automatic download (SEE BELOW)

I've also been to my iTunes Store > Purchased - and there is no record of me ever downloading this album (SEE BELOW)

I downloaded the album on this computer a very long time ago. It's really annoying and just wondered how i can stop it happening.

Thanks for anyone who can help!