How to enable Automatic Login?
Automatic Login option is set to off and is uneditable.
System Preferences -> Users & Groups -> Login Options - > Automatic login: Off
Uneditable. The pull-down is grayed out. The sheet is unlocked and I can make other edits such as "Show Password Hints."
A Guest login is enabled.
FileVault is enabled.
Firewall is On.
I have this same config on another Mt. Lion machine and am able to enable automatic login.
New MacBook Air
MacBook Air, OS X Mountain Lion (10.8.3)