Aperture vs. Lightroom - Black and White and Color Casting
Hey guys,
I've recently received Aperture and started playing with it... One of the major things I've notices is that control for making B&W Photos and Tones B&W photos seems to be a little more functional in Lightroom than in Aperture. Has anyone else found this to be true? If so, how did you get around the (seeming) limitations?
For example, lightroom applies different amounts of color toning to highlights and shadows enabling you to give the photo a much more contrastier look... Also, Aperture only lets you adjust RGB values when converting to B&W while lightroom gives you a wider selection of colors to control...
Am I wrong in saying all of the above? Is there something I'm missing about Aperture's color toning and B&W shading that I'm missing that puts it even or above Lightroom?
Thanks,
Ricardo
I've recently received Aperture and started playing with it... One of the major things I've notices is that control for making B&W Photos and Tones B&W photos seems to be a little more functional in Lightroom than in Aperture. Has anyone else found this to be true? If so, how did you get around the (seeming) limitations?
For example, lightroom applies different amounts of color toning to highlights and shadows enabling you to give the photo a much more contrastier look... Also, Aperture only lets you adjust RGB values when converting to B&W while lightroom gives you a wider selection of colors to control...
Am I wrong in saying all of the above? Is there something I'm missing about Aperture's color toning and B&W shading that I'm missing that puts it even or above Lightroom?
Thanks,
Ricardo
DC 2.0 G5, Mac OS X (10.4.6)