Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Need to edit 24p .mts files on FCP 5

Hello! I have been looking for answers for days on message boards, but I'm going in circles chasing only "possible causes" and can't find my specific problem, for obvious reasons.

To start: I'm a cameraperson, inexperienced on FCP. I am a very poor student filming with borrowed equipment, trying to edit on what I could afford, at home, so I realize there will be groans about my trying to use a dinosaur program (FCP5) on a dinosaur machine. The answer when it comes to technology is always "buy the new thing, it'll solve all of your problems." I can't, so I need help from anyone kind enough to help:


Trying to make a <23min film, total runtime (shooting at approx 4:1 ratio, so in total I'm trying to keep my footage to less than 90min) .

Using PowerMac G5 1TB main HD (OS 10.5.8) (computer entirely devoted to FCP only, I don't care about file size or time to render etc.), 4GB RAM

I want to shoot (have shot some) 1080/24p FX footage on a Sony AX2000, .mts files.

I chose DV-NTSC 24p (23.98) Advanced Pulldown Removal in setup.

I first chose HD (720x480) NTSC DV (3:2) in Sequence Settings... I see lots of answers to this size in canvas problem are related to matching this up with the imported video.

Because there is no Log and Transfer in FCP5, no way of converting to this "ProRes", I converted the .mts files with iSkysoft to .MP4 (though I'm not sure if that's a conversion with minimal loss. I also tried pulling them in as MPEG2, no audio came in so, wrong again...).

When I brought the MP4s into FC in this manner, they are fine in viewer, tiny in canvas. I can't see what I'm doing over there.

So, I looked at the clips in bin, item properties --->it shows they are only 320x240.

If they are automatically shrunken to edit 24p more quickly and easily, does an editor have to look at a small canvas to do all the edits, then it becomes full quality, regular size when it gets exported, presumably to quicktime?


I just want to bring in files and know that what I've edited, what I'm looking at, is pretty accurate to what others will see in a presentation like powerpoint, then can be uploaded to a site similar to youtube.


If I cannot edit this 24p, could someone describe to me an alternate recording format which can be more easily accomodated in FCP's preferences? If I should use another recording format, what easy setup do I choose for it and what sequence setting matches it?


Thank you so much

Final Cut Pro 5-OTHER, Mac OS X (10.5.8)

Posted on May 31, 2013 8:35 PM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on Jun 1, 2013 10:54 AM

Someone jump in if I am not recalling what is in FCP5 correctly . . . . but my suggestion would be:


Download Clipwrap (make sure you download the leagacy version for your older OS) at


http://www.divergentmedia.com/clipwrap


They have a free trail offer that will transfer the 1st minute or so of each clip, that should be more than enough to test this before you buy it.


Convert the mts clips to AIC Apple Intermediate Codec. It is not a particularly good codec, but might be the best choice given your hardware. I don't recall what the other available HD codecs are in FCP 5.


Now import the converted clips into FCP, and drop one of them on the timeline. Are you prompted by FCP to match the properties of source clip? If so, say yes. (I don't remember if this feature was on FCP 5 or not, if it does not proimpt you, then you will need to manually match all your Sequence Settings to all your source Item Properties.)


Then you should be good to start editing.


MtD

9 replies
Question marked as Best reply

Jun 1, 2013 10:54 AM in response to PhotographyMachine

Someone jump in if I am not recalling what is in FCP5 correctly . . . . but my suggestion would be:


Download Clipwrap (make sure you download the leagacy version for your older OS) at


http://www.divergentmedia.com/clipwrap


They have a free trail offer that will transfer the 1st minute or so of each clip, that should be more than enough to test this before you buy it.


Convert the mts clips to AIC Apple Intermediate Codec. It is not a particularly good codec, but might be the best choice given your hardware. I don't recall what the other available HD codecs are in FCP 5.


Now import the converted clips into FCP, and drop one of them on the timeline. Are you prompted by FCP to match the properties of source clip? If so, say yes. (I don't remember if this feature was on FCP 5 or not, if it does not proimpt you, then you will need to manually match all your Sequence Settings to all your source Item Properties.)


Then you should be good to start editing.


MtD

Jun 1, 2013 1:43 PM in response to Meg The Dog

I thought Clipwrap was the solution but I checked and don't believe it supports 10.5. If the OP does the trial, we'll soon find out.


Downloading the Panasonic AVCCAM Importer will allow you to open mts in MPEG Streamclip…but it also wants 10.6 at a minimum.


So I was going to suggest moving up to 10,6, but there are many reports of freezes etc with FCP 5 on SL.


A bit of a dilema. Hopefully Clipwrap and 10.5 will coexist peacefully.


Russ

Jun 1, 2013 4:23 PM in response to Meg The Dog

Many, many thanks everyone. Now, using (trial as of now) of Clip Converter Legacy, the clips I import into my bin are 1920x1080, so this is miles better and I can see what I'm doing on canvas.


Now that the image on the canvas is larger, I'm toying around trying to match up sequence settings to the item properties of the converted file, so it's all over the place and not quite right when I have matched every element I can, size, pixels etc...


Thank you so much, I'll see if I can fix this canvas/properties agreement issue without bugging you guys any more.

Need to edit 24p .mts files on FCP 5

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.