Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

ExFat Flash Drive Read Only

I let a friend borrow my 64G Flash Drive and he returned it with a bunch of unwanted files. At first I tried deleting them but all I got was a dull "beep" so I figured I'd just erase the whole thing and reformat. Opened disk utility and it was recognized but the options to erase are greyed out. Looked at the drive's info and it says "Read Only".


I have Paragon's NTSF driver installed thinking that would cure the erase problem but that did nothing. I know no one with a Windows machine so I can't ask someone else to reformat the drive for me.


How do I get the Flash Drive out of read only, erase and reformat to Mac OS Extended (Journaled)?

Mac Pro, OS X Mountain Lion (10.8.2), 3.6GHz 32G RAM 32TB HD Memory

Posted on Jul 28, 2013 5:10 PM

Reply
24 replies

Jul 28, 2013 6:15 PM in response to Linc Davis

I tested it with my own MacBook and got the same status. I took it down to my neighbor who has a MacBook Pro and got the same results there.


All systems recognize it under Disk Utility and report it as being formatted as ExFAT and "NO" to Owner Enabled - whereas all the other drives on my system report Mac OS Extended (Journaled) and YES to Owner Enabled


I don't know who formatted it as ExFAT although I see it as an option on both of my systems. I was sure I formatted it as OS Extended Journaled when I passed it on to my friend but the drive says it is ExFAT. He swears he didn't touch the formatting and did not let anyone else use the drive. If I had formatted as ExFat then it should report it as Owner Enabled.


I'm stumped. There should be a way to remove the read only status to free up the drive for reformatting.

Jul 28, 2013 6:35 PM in response to nbar

I'm only as positive as it is reported in Disk Drive which says it is ExFAT. When I check the available format methods for all my other drives I have the option to format with the Windows NT Filesystem but when I try and look at the formatting options under the Flash Drive, which fall under the Erase tab, I am stymied because Erase, RAID and Restore are greyed out. Under First Aid I do have the option to Verify the drive but not Repair or verify/repair Permissions.


When I Verify the drive the response is "The volume Flash Drive 65G appears to be OK."

Jul 28, 2013 7:00 PM in response to TheOS2Guy

when I try and look at the formatting options under the Flash Drive, which fall under the Erase tab, I am stymied because Erase, RAID and Restore are greyed out.

Does this apply to the drive, or just the partition on the drive (the volume). You want the drive.

Attaching a screenshot may help in your reply.


User uploaded file

Jul 28, 2013 7:15 PM in response to nbar

It applies to both the drive and the partition (volume). The only difference is on the drive I cannot verify the drive where I can verify the volume.


I do have Crossover installed and downloaded a Windows disk utility (three actually), installed them but they only recognized two disks, both at 76G but they don't see or report the flash drive. BTW, I have no internal or external drive smaller than 2 and 3G in size so the utility is not seeing anything beyond 76G on drive 1 and 2.


User uploaded file

Jul 29, 2013 3:56 PM in response to TheOS2Guy

No, I am just out of suggestions. I am following the thread. This was the format beforehand, correct? Your friend used the drive on a PC, and when it was returned this is what occurred. Only an NTFS formatted drive should behave this way. I am unaware of any fix, but I will follow the thread and see if other community members can offer a solution. Best of luck.

Aug 2, 2013 12:51 PM in response to Grant Bennet-Alder

I don't know anyone who uses Windows and took it to a Coffee House to ask if someone there would reformat it for me. Most of the time I got a 'no' fearing it may harm their systems (???) and those willing to had no idea how to perform a reformat. I figured it couldn't be that difficult on a Windows machine, there must be a disk utility somewhere on the system, but they wouldn't let me look or even try.


I did contact the manufacturer and was told the drive should work under OS X but they have never tested it and would not allow me to return it because the purchase date was beyond the 60-day warranty. I did tell them that I would alert the Mac community about the problem and suggest Mac users avoid PNY flash drives or other drives.


Because it was a 64G flash drive I paid a handsome price for it from Staples. I returned it to Staples and asked for my money back but again, according to my receipt, it was beyond their warranty period. Of course, they took me to the locked flash drive cabinet and suggested I purchase another brand but I was ticked and promised I would not buy another item from them.


I've asked the (former) friend who borrowed it to replace it with a different brand and mailed it to him because it contains all of his files. He has not responded thus far and I doubt that he ever will. Its too bad. I'll never loan another Flash Drive to anyone again, good friend or not.

Dec 6, 2013 11:32 AM in response to TheOS2Guy

I found this post while researching this issue, and it's recent enough that I figured you might like to hear the fix.


I bought a 128GB PNY StorEDGE from Amazon. Despite the item being marketed directly at "MacBooks," and the packaging saying "formatted for Mac" it was actually formatted ExFAT by an XP machine which is where this particular problem originates (evidently other OSs can format it and it won't get locked into this "read-only" mode).


I found an old Apple article saying to boot from a 10.5 DVD and use the Terminal while booted from the DVD, but the commands were deprecated Leopard versions. My MacBook is new enough that it won't even boot from my old Snow Leopard DVD, and when I tried the command line utilities in my boot drive's Mavericks Terminal, even the new versions of the command line disk utility wouldn't work.


What I didn't realize, was that it wasn't the particular utility that mattered, but the fact that the Mac was booted from an alternate boot drive. Eventually I booted from a Mavericks/UniBeast installer I had on a USB thumb drive in my backpack, and used the GUI Disk Utility in the Mavericks Installer. It was no longer read-only, and I was able to reformat it easily. Now that it's no longer XP/FAT I can use the boot drive's Disk Utility to alter it at will.

Dec 6, 2013 2:53 PM in response to Kurt Murray

Could not get Unibeast to install on an 8G flash drive using a Mavericks Mac. I'm left with a 65G flash drive that is formatted for ExFat and read-only that cannot and will not be erased and reformatted for OS X. Arghhh! Don't know why Unibeast won't install on an 8G Flash, too small? Or is it that Unibeast can only be installed using a Windows system? All options are greyed out when using the Disk Utility on the 65G flash drive.

ExFat Flash Drive Read Only

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.