Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Extending WiFi Network - Options

Have any of you used the Ubiquiti UniFi Pro to extend an AirPort Extreme WiFi network? Neither my 2.4 nor 5ghz networks are extending as far nor as strongly as I'd like and I'm looking into options for boosting and extending. The UniFi Pro has great reviews on Amazon, but they could be fake and I don't know anyone who has one and I wonder how well or if it plays nicely with Extremes. So, have any of you tried it? Or what are using and how well is it strengthening and extending your signal(s)? Thanks.

Mac mini, OS X Mountain Lion (10.8.3), OS X Server

Posted on Aug 20, 2013 12:24 PM

Reply
Question marked as Best reply

Posted on Aug 20, 2013 3:52 PM

I don't have the Ubiquiti, but I would have reservations on whether it could actually extend the Extreme's Wi-Fi network. That is because, the AirPort routers use a propriety method for wireless network extending. The Extreme works just fine with other Apple routers for extending or being extended by ... but not with wireless routers provided by other manufacturers.

7 replies
Question marked as Best reply

Aug 20, 2013 3:52 PM in response to carboncanyon

I don't have the Ubiquiti, but I would have reservations on whether it could actually extend the Extreme's Wi-Fi network. That is because, the AirPort routers use a propriety method for wireless network extending. The Extreme works just fine with other Apple routers for extending or being extended by ... but not with wireless routers provided by other manufacturers.

Aug 20, 2013 3:59 PM in response to Tesserax

Tesserax wrote:


I don't have the Ubiquiti, but I would have reservations on whether it could actually extend the Extreme's Wi-Fi network.

Reservations is too mild.. It won't work.


The Ubiquiti is a totally different system. Plug it into the main router by ethernet and set it up.. I have some older ubiquiti stuff and it is not so easy to setup.


I would stick to using Apple with Apples.. if you want to extend wireless apple compliant way.


Ubiquiti stuff is great for a larger more professional setup.

Aug 20, 2013 8:18 PM in response to LaPastenague

LaPastenague wrote:


It won't work.


The Ubiquiti is a totally different system. Plug it into the main router by ethernet and set it up.. I have some older ubiquiti stuff and it is not so easy to setup.


I would stick to using Apple with Apples.. if you want to extend wireless apple compliant way.


Ubiquiti stuff is great for a larger more professional setup.


I'm using the Extreme as my main router. My ISP installed an Alcatel-Lucent ONT in my basement which is directly connected to fiber optic on the street and then runs a Cat5e up to my study. But I have a smart tv, a Roku, two airplay stereos, an iPad, an iPhone, a printer and a laptop in different parts of the house which are fighting for pretty weak signals. I have a lot of very close neighbors, all of whom are using wifi and some of whom are using channels like 2, 4, 7, etc. so completely clogging up the crowded spectrum.


I wanted the "professional" solution because it extends and strengthens the 5ghz and 2.4 simultaneously and I particularly want to strengthen and extend my 5ghz signal so I won't be packed in like a sardine on the 2.4.


I'm not worried about "difficult to set up"; I can figure most things out with enough time and focus. But if it won't work at all, obviously, that would have to be removed as an option. I'm really not interested in setting up 5 Expresses to do what one device like the UniFi Pro can do; what I've read indicates that the Expresses aren't terribly powerful and the hardware is out of date, at this point, so it would be a waste of money to spend on a half dozen of these things to cover the area.


So, what other options exist to do this in one shot? And is there any clarification on why the Extreme cannot work with non-Apple wifi repeaters/extenders, if that's so? Seems like an enormous limitation. Enough to make me consider returning it. This is a replacement after the first one I got was defective. I'll be hardwiring my smart TV next week, but that doesn't solve the problem of having a weak signal in the room with the Extreme and low/no signal in the back half of my house and the 3rd floor.

Aug 20, 2013 9:35 PM in response to carboncanyon

is there any clarification on why the Extreme cannot work with non-Apple wifi repeaters/extenders


It is so.. Apple march to their own drum.. I have not bothered to track down the why.. but I have to say if you haven't done wireless extend before you will not find apple all that unusual.. eg the ubiquiti system is probably unique .. so you couldn't use another brand in that mix either. And most WDS systems in routers are great as long as you buy another identical router.. Wireless has no proper extend standard.. nor do universal repeaters actually work properly.


I'll be hardwiring my smart TV next week, but that doesn't solve the problem of having a weak signal in the room with the Extreme and low/no signal in the back half of my house and the 3rd floor.


Of course you should get good signal in the room you are connecting it in. If not then do return it..


See our local Aussie support forum for a test of AC extreme vs Asus.


http://forums.whirlpool.net.au/forum-replies.cfm?t=2125865


There is a link there to the Smallnetbuilder review which got the same results.. Asus thrashes it.


Use roaming with a second Asus where you hardwire.. that gives the best results.. do not extend wireless at all.. use ethernet backbone and multiple WAPs.

Aug 20, 2013 9:50 PM in response to carboncanyon

Apple does everything in their power to make users buy other Apple products when they want to extend a signal from another Apple router wirelessly.


Over the past few years, I've learned from experience that......


Cisco won't extend Apple

Linksys won't extend Apple

Actiontec won't extend Apple

Arris won't extend Apple


I think you might get the idea.


Of course, no one has tested every product from every manufacturer to develop a comprehensive list of what won't work, but it would be an accurate statement to say that it would be extremely unlikely that a third party product would be able to extend an Apple wireless signal wirelessly.


Unless you have a lot of time and patience, are willing to experiment, and have a liberal return policy, you might consider using other Apple products to extend the wireless network....or.....decide on another vendor for your routing requirements.


No matter what brand you might choose, extending using Ethernet to all wireless access points will perform much, much better than trying to use wireless to extend the signal from device to device.

Dec 19, 2013 8:59 PM in response to Bob Timmons

I"m not sure what everyone is talking about here. I am a casual user, homeowner, not a network specialist at all. I have an Apple Airport Extreme, maybe three years old. It wouldn't quite cover all parts of the house, so I extended it using a Netgear wireless hub (may not be exactly the correct term). The point is, Apple plays fine with my Netgear device.

Extending WiFi Network - Options

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.