My suggestion to Apple: Re-name Music to Audio and put the Podcast option back in (just like Audiobooks is allowed to remain there). While you're at it, when a user selects the option to transcode "songs" at a lower bitrate in iTunes, include Podcasts just llke you do Audiobooks.
Within six months I'll be in the smartphone market again and won't buy another iOS device if I can't manage my files with the reasonable flexibility of iOS 6. I'm already saving for a possible iPad to update my old one. I won't if it comes with the current Music/Podcast App. That's about $1,000-$1,500 of disposable income Apple is telling me to spend elsewhere. That doesn't count the impulse buys they aren't getting since I can't even play with their new radio feature. Big dollars and little pennies both.
My issues are below (and are similar to what I've sent via Feedback, which I encourage all to do if you haven't already):
The only reason I haven't updated to iOS 7 is issues with the Music App (inability to delete entire albums or artists on the fly, expanded album view, etc.) and, more significantly, my issues with how it isn't allowed to handle podcasts. I have a lot of experience with the Podcast app. I understand the workarounds listed above and have considered an alternative like Downcast, but so much time is already invested in this that if Apple makes workarounds and supplementary apps necessary, I'd rather seek Apple-free alternatives by voting my dollars elsewhere. And I don't want to do that.
I have an iPod (5g) and an iPad (2g). On the iPod I listen to downloaded podcasts synced from my Mac (since the app no longer allows downloads through it). This is the most stable, reliable and frustration-free experience. I reverted to this method when what follows happened on both devices:
On the iPad I use the Podcast app so that I can stream and not rely on syncing as much. Features like On-The-Go and my stations are nice but the app itself is highly unstable, even after removing, re-installing and resetting the device. The three most common issues I have:
- After a podcast ends it rarely continues to the next one. The app just hangs for a minute and then crashes.
- When selecting a podcast (especially while another one is playing) the app stalls and, assuming it doesn't crash, it kicks back to the main list at the very top and I have to scroll down an incredibly lengthy list of recent/on-the-go list to see if I can stumble on where I was.
- Less common, but most frustratingly, sometimes the app will crash mid-podcast. Fortunately, re-opening it after some time stuck on blank page will lead me back to the podcast where a little before I left off.
Re-installing and restoring the device has not helped, it's only forced me to go through the time-consuming process of organizing things again.
Beyond that, simply managing downloads is unecessarily cumbersome:
- if I download a podcast for later offline listening the only way to find the specifically downloaded content is to go to Settings->Usage->Podcasts and see the programs that are saved then go back to the app and find them. No workaround will solve this.
- If I want to delete one of these podcasts, since there is no "Downloaded Podcasts" tab/button, I have to go into settings to find them or, as above, just hunt the long list.
- The general process of tapping little blue circles to get to submenus that take me to pop-up menus is fine if incredibly inelegant for a company that prides itself on elegance, but considering the instabilities listed above, if I accidentally miss the circle then more than likely I have to deal with hanging and crashing then finding my podcast again.
- The only way to sync saved Podcasts back to my computer is to "Transfer purchases," which has to be done through iTunes and can't be done through standard syncing.
Then there's managing the podcasts themselves:
- My Stations is wonderful in theory, but they are difficult to organize since you can't sort or search the menu to add titles to a station. Add to that, if you *do* sort them, the sorting doesn't transfer to additional devices, so sorting can be different on every device even if they all pull the same titles from the cloud.
- Having many interests, I subscribe to a LOT of podcasts. I do not listen to every episode of every entry, but only the episodes of particular interest. As such, I rely on smart playlists to help keep organized. The Podcast app doesn't support those. Sure, My Stations and On-the-go help, but in addition to the complications listed above, the "Recent" list seems to bundle podcasts (e.g., some NPR programs release two episodes per day and only the most recent one shows up on the list, so it's easy to miss a potentially interesting topic).
As such, my simplest mode of listening to podcasts is through the music app on iOS 6. I created a few smart playlists that give me a logical variety of the most recent files, some of the oldest I've missed, some of the largest/longest (so I can listen to them first and free up more space). There is NO such flexibility in using the Podcast app, even if the My Stations feature is clearly trying to provide an alternative.