Hi, Robert -
Startup Manager, invoked via holding the Option key at startup, can display only one OS per volume - and will display the last OS booted to on that volume.
Article #106178 - Startup Manager: How to Select a Startup Volume
You should be able to use the Startup Disk control pane in System Preferences to set OS 9 as the boot OS, then restart into it.
This is, of course, assuming your machine is OS 9 bootable. Not all G4 MDDs are.
***
If you do want to be able to use Startup Manager to pick between the two, you will need to get the two OS's onto separate volumes, either separate partitions or separate drives.