So much arguing over who is at fault in this thread, but how about this - what's the logic of preventing the return of an iPhone?
Apple does not allow you to register the location of the phone - for return to the original owner.
They don't let you contact the original owner.
They brick the device, but absolutely do not facilitate any return of the phone - of any kind, at all.
They are not preventing theft. They aren't expediting the returns of phones. They are merely bricking devices.
The reality is, a great many phones are being bricked by Apple - that were not stolen.
But even those that were stolen, aren't being returned.
I bought a phone, the seller said it had a clean ESN - I checked online before making the purchase, it did have a clean ESN.
But the seller plain didn't disclose the phone was activation locked. Dishonest seller, happens all the time.
So my first inclination is to contact the person whose account is blocking the activation, to see if it was stolen - can't. Apple doesn't allow that.
Or I could, give Apple my email address, so they could contact me - can't. Apple doesn't allow that.
Did any of you ask yourself what happens to these bricked phones? They get placed in the trash, that's what happens.
If its stolen, and there was the opportunity to return it - what a ridiculous absurd logic, that doesn't allow any returns or even the possibility of a return.
And cut the nonsense about calling the police. I called the police, they just said it wasn't registered as stolen. Phone is still bricked. I still have the phone - waiting to be trashed.