Can't Paste Adjustments

I'm trying to copy adjustments from one clip and paste them to another.

As outlined in the manual, I applied the desired adjustments to the first clip. Then, I selected the clip in its entirety and chose Edit > Copy. Then, I Command-clicked the clip I wanted to copy the adjustments to, and chose Edit > Paste Adjustments. However, all of the paste options are grayed out. I've tried with multiple clips and no luck.

Anyone else having the same problem, or have a fix?