How to read/write to NTFS-3G formatted USB drives?

I had no problems writing and reading to NTFS-3G formatted drives from my Macbook Pro when using Snow Leopard. I then avoided Mountain Lion on the rpinciple of "If it ain't broke, don't fix it!". My Macbook did everything I asked of it. However, I (stupidly?) installed Mavericks not long ago. Aside from now running VERY slow, I seem to have lost the ability to read/write to a USB drive that I formatted as NTFS-3G, using Disc Utility in Snow Leopard.

Can someone please explain - very simply for technologically challenged users like me - how to restore access to NTFS-3G file formats? I don't really want to pay Paragon, as I have never had to buy 3rd party software to have cross-platform functionality before.

PS I hope Apple is not doing a Gates here, and placing obstacles in the way of cross-platform users.

MacBook Pro, OS X Mavericks (10.9)

Posted on Nov 21, 2013 3:47 AM

Reply
10 replies

Nov 21, 2013 6:55 AM in response to a brody

I think either we have a communication problem, or else we are in parallel universes here. Disc Utility has for years offered me the option of formatting an external USB drive in NTFS-3G (as well as MSDOS Fat, Mac Extended etc). Until I installed Mavericks, I have been using a Samsung 1 terrabyte drive formatted on my Mac as NTFS-3G. I have used this to swap files back and forth between PC devices and my Macbook. I have never knowingly purchased any 3rd party software to enable my Mac to do this. (Just a thought - maybe Macfuse was somehow installed some years ago and worked until Mavericks?) But when I plugged this USB drive into the Mac, the new regime of Mavericks refused to recognise it. All that lost data. And then it refused to erase and format it as an NTFS-3G drive, despite this being one of the options on the pull-down menu.

So anyway, the main issue now is I want to know how to do with Mavericks what I have been able to do for years with older OS Xs ie format an external drive as NTFS-3G and then use it to swap files back and forth between Microsoft based devices and my Mac laptop. Oh, and I need to format as NTFS-3G, not MSDOS Fat, as some of the files I swap are larger than 4 GB.

Nov 21, 2013 3:07 PM in response to a brody

We are indeed living in parallel universes, and having communication problems as well. I just want to restore previously accessible functions on my Mac after the installation of Mavericks WITHOUT going to a 3rd party provider. Please note my original post:

"I don't really want to pay Paragon, as I have never had to buy 3rd party software to have cross-platform functionality before."

Nov 21, 2013 3:42 PM in response to CB500X

CB500X wrote:


I think either we have a communication problem, or else we are in parallel universes here. Disc Utility has for years offered me the option of formatting an external USB drive in NTFS-3G (as well as MSDOS Fat, Mac Extended etc).

NTFS-3G is a 3rd party non standard utility to enable NTFS writes in OSX. It is old and is not compatible with Mavericks.


Uninstall it before it causes more problems.


Paragon is reliable, supported, and won't fail everytime Apple update OSX. It's your data, how much is it worth?





I just want to restore previously accessible functions on my Mac after the installation of Mavericks WITHOUT going to a 3rd party provider.


NTFS-3G is from a 3rd party provider, the file system it allows write access to is called NTFS, and it's Microsofts.

Nov 21, 2013 6:48 PM in response to Csound1

Thanks CSound1

I'm aware that NTFS belongs to Microsoft. That's why it works in PC devices - and its why I want it.

I wasn't aware that NTFS-3G is actually a utility rather than a file system, and not an Apple approved one at that, as it can be found in Apple's Disc Utility on the drop down menu. BTW, does this mean any 3rd party develop can change Apple's software to make it appear to be a part of the Apple system?

I see from my brief Google that the NTFS-3G utlity was developed as open source software by the same people who developed Tuxera. And no, I will not buy 3rd party software. If the Mac can't do the job on its own, then I will use my girlfriend's old PC to organise and back up my movies and music. The Mac can stay as my work machine. Don't you just hate how manufacturers are so keen to prevent cross platform communication? It's like electrical plugs, where the many different varieties internationally may pee off the travelling consumer, but the practice makes a mint for the manufacturers. Oh for the simplicity of a rational world where standardisation is acceptable and capitalism controlled.


Nov 21, 2013 7:18 PM in response to CB500X

Apple at least make an attempt at cross platform support. OSX natively supports FAT32 and includes Read support for NTFS, Microsoft supports no other file systems but there own.


Paragon is however worth the price (they also do the reverse of this by offering an excellent MacOS interpreter for Windows)


But your method is a little cheaper.

Nov 21, 2013 7:19 PM in response to CB500X

The only way NTFS-3G could have been present in Disk Utility on your previous OS Install is if you, or someone else, installed NTFS-3G onto your computer at some point (possibly in a bundle of some kind, but it was installed by someone)


Not sure what you mean by "changing Apple's software"...various parts of the OS are designed to allow third-party components to extend their functionality. It's called a plugin architecture, and is what allows you to (for example) view Flash video in Safari if you want to even though Apple doesn't support Flash natively.


This is a good thing. The alternative would be that Apple would have to support everything under the sun (never happen. It's just not possible), or you would be limited to using only what Apple chooses to natively support (and no Flash or Java for you).


As for standardization, there's plenty of it in modern computers (such as the USB, RAM and other peripherals). File systems are proprietary. Apple doesn't fully support other companies' proprietary file systems (but does support the open source ones). Microsoft doesn't support HFS+ either. So what. Still far better than what you'd get if some government agency tried to regulate all the standards (which would be no computers at all, I suspect, or at best the equivalent of the old VIC-20).


And there's absolutely nothing wrong with capitalism.

Nov 21, 2013 7:20 PM in response to CB500X

I should have mentioned in my last post - the reason I want Microsoft based format for movies and music is that my TV and sound system both rely on Microsoft. I suspect the vast majority of TVs and sound systems do at present, so it then makes it important to have a means of transferring movies and sound files from my Mac to a USB drive that plugs into my TV / sound system. (And no, I am not going to buy Apple TV to try to get around the TV issue). My next online adventure will be to discover where to buy music and movies from a Microsoft formatted computer. I'm sure my defection won't send Apple shares down. But if many others are like me and find their PC based entertainment devices are not compatible with their Mac laptops, it may help Amazon and Google along. The one great feature about capitalism is competition - and we need more of it!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

How to read/write to NTFS-3G formatted USB drives?

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.