In terms of RAM speed, going asymetrical will SLOW DOWN your machine, which is now working with superfast dual-channel memory access, whilst with the asymmetrical configuration this super speed will not be possible anymore.
So I suppose that you will be disappointed changing just one memory chip, the machine will be SLOWER than now...
More RAM means more speed only when you run out of memory, and the system is forced to read/write data from the mass storage. A situation which should be avoided as much as possible, so in this end maxing the RAM at 16 Gb AND DISABLING AT ALL the virtual memory on disk is the only reliable solution.
This is also quite important if you replace the HD with a fast SSD (which is better not to use for virtual memory, as this ages it prematurely).
My machine had a big speed increase, because I simultaneously installed the 16 GB RAM, and a fast SSD. And this is what I recommend to every Macbook pro owner. Buy 16 Gb of RAM (Crucial, possibly), and an M500 960Gb SSD. You will get a completely different beast, booting in less than 15s, launching heavy apps in 2-3 seconds, etc...
Ok, this upgrade is expensive, but I can ensure you that it is plenty worth the money.
Doing it just at half (expanding the RAM without the SSD, or vice versa, or, even worst, changing just one of the two memory chips) is as wearing two different shoes... You will never walk properly...