Jot Flip (from 2012) with disk nib on iPad 3
Pros:
- Base models quite cheap now! (≈$20-30).
- Quiet.
- Doesn't 'miss' sections of writing with a screen protector.
- Nib lasts far longer with continued use than any rubber stylus I've used (they all broke 1 month or so in).
- Very precise and simple (i.e. no battery & easy to see tip placement).
Cons:
- Nib requires replacement every 3-4 months (given everyday use).
- Grit caught between nib and screen protector causes scratches (and frosting long term).
- Nib can break off or become loose with excessive wear (Although you can sometimes just reattach if you can find it!).
- The very fluid writing feel takes a bit of time to get used to (very low friction).
I've been using a Jot Flip by Adonit for the last two years or so. Wonderful stylus! Main drawback is that the plastic disk at the tip tends to wear down after 3-4 months (mind you, it's in constant use throughout the uni semester...) and if you have a screen protector, the stylus will completely ruin it over time. This seems to happen whenever a small piece of dust or grit gets stuck between the disk nib and the screen, and this will generally make the screen protector frosty with continued use, with the occasional deep gouge. As a result I haven't been game enough to try the stylus without a screen protector for fear of damaging the glass (which most likely is considerably tougher than a plastic film). Other than this, it's a great stylus, and the price has dropped quite a bit since I bought mine in 2012. Not too noisy either (especially if you're used to running-writing).
Also, if you're considering a rubber tip, they're no good for long-term use. I found the tip (incredibly smooth at first) became overly grippy with continued use. It ended up leaving dark marks on the screen from wear (just rubber marks, which could be scrubbed off) and subsequently the grip caused the rubber to fault and tear. Very frustrating.