HT202023: About in-app purchases

Learn about About in-app purchases
King Vidor

Q: Why is Clash of Clans claiming insufficient funds?

I have $51.37 in my iTunes account and I'm trying to make an in-app purchase for $49.99 in Clash of Clans. The game keeps telling me I have insufficient funds. Whats going on?  Is C of C taking additional cash out of my account beyond the purchase? 

iPad

Posted on Feb 10, 2014 6:54 PM

Close

Q: Why is Clash of Clans claiming insufficient funds?

  • All replies
  • Helpful answers

  • by roaminggnome,

    roaminggnome roaminggnome Feb 10, 2014 8:41 PM in response to King Vidor
    Level 10 (96,899 points)
    Feb 10, 2014 8:41 PM in response to King Vidor

    You do not have enough to cover the cost of the app and the taxes.

  • by King Vidor,

    King Vidor King Vidor Feb 12, 2014 8:06 AM in response to roaminggnome
    Level 1 (0 points)
    Feb 12, 2014 8:06 AM in response to roaminggnome

    Taxes?  Illinois does not have taxation on internet purchases unless the retailer has a legal nexus within the state .  I know because I have an online business in Illinois.  Unless the developers/distributors of this product, or iTunes,  has a legal permanent mailing address in Illinois, which they don't, then this should not be going on.  Illinois does NOT require taxes be withdrawn from internet purchases outside of Illinois nor does the US have a VAT tax.  Other states cannot tax an Illinois purchase.  So again, where are these thousands of dollars going, because I know I'm not the only one being "taxed"?  Can you tell me specifically which jurisdiction or government body is taxing these purchases and at what percent?  Thank you

  • by stedman1,

    stedman1 stedman1 Feb 12, 2014 8:15 AM in response to King Vidor
    Level 9 (73,365 points)
    Apple Watch
    Feb 12, 2014 8:15 AM in response to King Vidor

    Taxes will be charged at whatever rate exist for the city/state from which you are ordering.

  • by King Vidor,

    King Vidor King Vidor Feb 12, 2014 8:34 AM in response to stedman1
    Level 1 (0 points)
    Feb 12, 2014 8:34 AM in response to stedman1

    If that is the story they are offering, then I'm afraid I have to disagree with you.  You only can collect taxes on internet sales from WITHIN the state where you have a physical nexus NOT across state lines.   Itunes does not operate a physical nexus (have an actual physical building) within Illinois, thus they cannot tax an Illinois purchase based on an Illinois address.  There IS NO internet tax and my purchase cannot be taxed by California (or wherever the iTunes base is now) unless I physically LIVE in that state.  Again, there is no reference to tax at time of purchase, no STATE mentioned at time of purchase and NO TAX RATE declared.  As an internet retailer, I can tell you, that is flirting with a lawsuit and a knock on the door from the FTC and possibly the IRS looking for their "tax" money.  It would be a book keeping nightmare for ANY retailer of ANY size to collect, catagorize and then distribute tax money to each and every state, county, city, and township in the U.S on a quarterly basis.  The internet would die a quick death.

  • by stedman1,

    stedman1 stedman1 Feb 12, 2014 8:37 AM in response to King Vidor
    Level 9 (73,365 points)
    Apple Watch
    Feb 12, 2014 8:37 AM in response to King Vidor

    I suspect the lawyers for Apple, Amazon, and all other online retailers are more than a little familiar with tax laws for online purchases. However, if you feel you are somehow more familiar with them, by all means initiate a class action law suit.

  • by King Vidor,

    King Vidor King Vidor Feb 12, 2014 8:56 AM in response to stedman1
    Level 1 (0 points)
    Feb 12, 2014 8:56 AM in response to stedman1

    Im sure the lawyers for Facebook were familiar with fraudulent "likes" as well but they got caught using fraudulent accounts to boost advertising sales.  Your snide comment shows you have no answer for this problem.  I am very familar with tax law Stedman, that is why I am giving an opportunity for someone within the community to come up with a logical explanation of why thousands of people, mostly unfamiliar with tax laws, are being taxed to the point of devaluation of their proper and rightful full value of purchase.  By the way, AMAZON does not tax interstate sales unless they have a nexus in the state.  Apple opened retail stores in most states so they now charge if the shipment is FROM Illinois to Illinois residents, but not across state lines.  APPs are an internet based download and thus come from a central data site, not individual retail stores.  So again, what state is taxing me and at what rate?

  • by NothingLasts1987,

    NothingLasts1987 NothingLasts1987 Apr 19, 2015 9:29 PM in response to King Vidor
    Level 1 (0 points)
    Apple Music
    Apr 19, 2015 9:29 PM in response to King Vidor

    I'd also like to know about this. I'll admit I hardly know the law but I was under the impression that Illinois didn't require tax on digital purchases. My guess is this has changed as I recently noticed tax on an Amazon app purchase and again on an iTunes app purchase. What strikes me as odd is neither purchase was up front and told me tax would be connected. I found out only when checking my receipt that was sent to my email.

     

    And yes, I do realize this discussion is from a year ago.