My MBP had a hdd problem that I solved but then the HDD died and the new hdd inherited some problems via time machine: running slow now

I bought this MacBook Pro about three years ago ... it worked well for two years then started having what turned out to be HDD problems. I managed to get the system working again but it was a bit slower. Then the HDD died. I was fully up to date with Time Machine and my new HDD took everything in its stride. However, whatever was causing the sloth on the old, sick, HDD, was inherited by the new HDD.


Is there something I can do/check to see what the problem might be??


AFAIK the new HDD is running perfectly.


I am running Mavericks, 2Gb RAM, 1Tb HDD ...


I have been using a clean up package to get rid of my dross and so far it has deleted about 90 Gb of clutter, so I am confident my system is as clean as it might be.

MacBook Pro, OS X Mountain Lion (10.8)

Posted on Mar 5, 2014 7:13 PM

Reply
20 replies

Mar 5, 2014 8:05 PM in response to Tony T1

Thanks Tony,


I bought the macbook determined that I would never fiddle with it. I have been using windows since 3.1 so have had to learn all sorts of things to keep the wretched things going.


If I click CMD+R, will the MBP just know what to do and just do it? Will I need to back up anything ... other than on time machine?


In other words, is it inuitive and relatively risk free!


Duncan

Mar 6, 2014 3:15 AM in response to duncanwil

duncanwil wrote:


If I click CMD+R, will the MBP just know what to do and just do it? Will I need to back up anything ... other than on time machine?


In other words, is it inuitive and relatively risk free!


Yes. See: http://support.apple.com/kb/PH13871

Only OS is restored (your filles ad setting are not touched), but to be safe, do a Time Machine backup.


BTW, CleanMyMac2 is not needed, you should uninstall it before you restore.

Mar 17, 2014 7:06 PM in response to TildeBee

Hello Bee and everyone!


Everything went well as far as the process was concerned. I had no difficulty with any of it. However, the same old rainbow wheel of death kept appearing, the system was still running slowly at times.


I discussed this kind of thing with a friend a while ago, he's a computer/wifi systems geek. He suggested installing a smallish (240 Gb) SSD in place of my 1 Tb HDD, running everything off that and having all of my working, documents, pictures etc on my backup drives ... I am doing that now.


I formatted the SSD, downloaded OS X Mt Lion and am currently upgrading to Mavericks.


I am using my time machine to bring back my data etc files and I will reinstall my software package by package.


I think it might be overkill as I did think that I could take my 1Tb HDD right back to the start and do the same.


Anyway, later today I will have Mavericks back, Office back, Adobe software back ... and I should be running at a good speed!!

Mar 18, 2014 3:12 AM in response to duncanwil

duncanwil wrote:


I discussed this kind of thing with a friend a while ago, he's a computer/wifi systems geek. He suggested installing a smallish (240 Gb) SSD in place of my 1 Tb HDD, running everything off that and having all of my working, documents, pictures etc on my backup drives ... I am doing that now.



You're running Mavericks with ojnly 2Gb RAM (the minimum requred for Mavericks)

RAM is a cheaper and easier upgrade, and you won't have to move documents to your backup drive (and you'll then need another drive to backup the backup drive 🙂


Get at least 4G, more if your Mac is able.

See: http://www.crucial.com/store/advisor.aspx

or: http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/apple/memory/

Mar 18, 2014 3:24 AM in response to duncanwil

duncanwil wrote:


Hello Bee and everyone!


Everything went well as far as the process was concerned. I had no difficulty with any of it. However, the same old rainbow wheel of death kept appearing, the system was still running slowly at times.


I discussed this kind of thing with a friend a while ago, he's a computer/wifi systems geek. He suggested installing a smallish (240 Gb) SSD in place of my 1 Tb HDD, running everything off that and having all of my working, documents, pictures etc on my backup drives ... I am doing that now.

You have insufficient Ram, something your Geek friend should have pointed out.


Add Ram.

Mar 18, 2014 5:20 AM in response to Csound1

That's a fair point and it IS one of the things my friend told me to do. I take the blame for everything I have done, however!


I've got the SSD running and settling in and I have to say Photoshop CC opened at a blistering pace. I mean 5 seconds v 50 seconds.


Why haven't I bought the memory yet? I live in rural Thailand and getting such memory is difficult with reliability. So, I wait until I travel for work, often to Kuala Lumpur. I bought the SSD there over the weekend. My track record with RAM there is iffy. I bought 2 Gb last year for my HP laptop and within a month it had failed. I bought replacement memory for the same machine earlier this year and that might have caused me problems, I think, as the video card crashed shortly afterwards. All repaired and working well now, including that latest memory. Maybe not a memory problem that time.


So, I am keen to wait until I can get some 100% copper bottomed reliable RAM for the Mac.


The performance has improved as I just demonstrated and I am sure I will find the same when I set to work on a large Word or Excel file.


In the meantime, the machine is still running hot, due to the low RAM I suppose!


Thanks again for your interesting as it is very useful for me to see these views and I am happy to explain my what and why!

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

My MBP had a hdd problem that I solved but then the HDD died and the new hdd inherited some problems via time machine: running slow now

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.