ARD not saving computer list

I was having issues with ARD authenticating clients, so I deleted and redownloaded the ARD software. After doing this the authentication work properly again, but ARD resets itself each time I close it.

When I close ARD, the computer list, password, and reporting settings erase themselves. The next time I open the software I have to agree to the license terms again, set a password, choose reporting options, and reenter my computer list.

Obviously there is some form of preferences issue, but I do not know what file might be corrupted. How can I make ARD save my computer list again? It is becoming rather tedious and annoying to renter it each time I launch the software...