Easy-to-hack MacBook

I saw an article on Netscape about a month ago saying that some hackers had found a "hole" in the security software for wireless cards on MacBooks and several PC laptops. This hole allowed them to seize absolute control over the computer, regardless of firewall and/or any other security configurations, if it had its wireless network card on.

They were supposed to tape this process (without revealing the method. they said they wouldn't do it live because of the big risk that someone might record the signal to find out what they did) to show a demonstration that network security, specially wireless, is not nearly as safe as people think.

I lost sight of this article and couldn't follow up, but according to netscape news this is true, and if so, why haven't we, macbook users, gotten any security update to correct that?

Are our MacBooks under this terrible threat?

2GHz MacBook, Mac OS X (10.4.7)

Posted on Sep 9, 2006 12:45 AM

Reply
7 replies

Sep 9, 2006 12:52 AM in response to DavidAngel

You should go back and read that again. They used a Mac in the example, but it also works on Windows and with the Linux drivers as well.

More so, it WAS NOT with the airport that comes with the mac. It was with a third party network card with drivers not made by Apple. Now think about it.. You MacBook Comes with and Airport card and there is no slot, like on the Pro version. So how can you use that card to be hacked? And even if you could, why would you? You have a non-hackable Apple airport already. Even if you had a macbook pro why would you install this cheap third party airport card?

Please go read that artical again.

Sep 9, 2006 7:15 AM in response to DavidAngel

Are our MacBooks under this terrible threat?


NO!

It was, to put it bluntly a SCAM. This had nothing to do with a MacBook being vulnerable at all. It was two hackers that wanted thier 15 minutes of fame.

Here are some related links:
Link One
Link Two
Link Three
And finally Link Four

I am not concerned about the wireless security of my MacBook at all.
🙂
Greg

Sep 9, 2006 8:05 AM in response to DavidAngel

For now let's just say that this report left more questions than it did answers. Was the hacked Macintosh using its internal WiFi or a third party WiFi card? There are conflicting claims. Was the Mac using Apple's WiFi drivers or third party drivers? Again, conflicting claims. Was the entire thing a scam from start to finish? Some are claiming exactly that.

The process that has been described is theoretically possible but is the Apple hardware and/or software vulnerable to this threat? No word from Apple but that shouldn't be taken as proof either way. Apple speaks only when Apple is ready to speak - the general rule of thumb is until Apple has a definitive answer there is no comment.

Since this article appeared there have been claims and counter claims, lawyerly obfuscations in the guise of commentary, and the only real truth is that suddenly the people who claim to have hacked the computer are now as silent as Apple.

Sep 9, 2006 9:09 AM in response to dwb

This is the subject of a massive thread at slashdot and I suggest reading Daring Fireball for a complete ripping apart of the claims. The hack as demonstrated was fake; they used a third party card and third party drivers and some other stuff which they happened to put in a MacBook to draw attention. Earlier this week, Johnny Cache came out and said some stuff about Apple coming down on them and intimating they had a hack that works on Apple's stuff - he gave enough detail to say the hack demonstrated relied on a flaw in Centrino technology. He did not, however, say he had a hack. He did not say Apple told him not to talk about it. He really didn't say anything much.

Sep 9, 2006 11:19 AM in response to Donald Fowler

You should go back and read that again. They used a
Mac in the example, but it also works on Windows and
with the Linux drivers as well.

More so, it WAS NOT with the airport that comes with
the mac. It was with a third party network card with
drivers not made by Apple. Now think about it.. You
MacBook Comes with and Airport card and there is no
slot, like on the Pro version. So how can you use
that card to be hacked? And even if you could, why
would you? You have a non-hackable Apple airport
already. Even if you had a macbook pro why would you
install this cheap third party airport card?

Please go read that artical again.


Hey, I remarked that the problem was also found on PC laptops. I'm not saying that the MacBook is a bad computer, I was just wondering if (IFFFFFFFF) that is true why haven't we had some security update about it.

Sep 9, 2006 11:24 AM in response to DavidAngel

In the article it said that they used a MacBook not because they had anything against apple, but because apple computer always says that their computers have a great firewall and are completely safe against spyware, viruses, etc. That could mean that they did the test on a macbook with other WiFi card just to show a macbook being hacked.

It could be that, but I was just worried because I never knew anything about that after reading that article.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Easy-to-hack MacBook

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.