My Review of My MacBook

I've had my macbook for a month now. So far, I really like it.

keyboard: easy to type on, except sometimes I feel like I need to stretch toward some keys.

screen: I don't particularly like the glossy. It's not the glaring problem, it's actually color "issues." Is it just me or does it seem like it has bad contrast ratio? People are saying it makes awesome blacks. Yea sure, only in certain angles, otherwise it seems like you're looking at an x-ray picture (off-black?). In other words, the black is not consistent throughout the screen. Matte screens is more consistent. When the screen shut off, there's a liquid effect, which i don't know if that's normal or not. Thankfully, no dead pixels!

trackpad: nice and big. the issue is sometimes the extreme sides do not respond. This requires me to move from the middle in order for the pointer to move again. I love the scrolling and secondary-click features.

discoloration: produces a blue tint on the edge where the wrist would lay.

battery: appear to last a length of 3:30 (didn't exactly timed it. the machine's calculation changes frequently).

other comments: it's pretty fast, but not the improvement I was expecting )from mac mini g4). Then again, I don't use much CPU-intensive apps. Installing ram was easy. The edges are sharp. Windows (by way of Boot Camp) have issues for me. Airport signal is strong, though the router is only a few feet away. Now that the fan firmware arrived, it's perfectly comfortable for lap use. The combo drive is dang loud.

Applecare (complimentary): the macbook was buzzing, as well as, and like, the power adapter and a discoloration. Looong wait times on phone. They try to do troubleshooting over the phone first. Moments later, they would allow send-in repair. Here, I was impressed as repair/exchange took 2-3 days. I sent in my power adapter and received a new one 2 days later (day 1: sent, day 2: they received and sent the replacement, day 3: received; applied for macbook as well). Except, they didn't seem to replace the keyboard cover, made the trackpad button squeak with their replacement (it was perfect before), and added an additional type of buzzing to the one I was complaining about when they replaced the fan. So it came back worse. Boooo!

In the end, if I have the option to return and get a refund, I would. For me it's like a mac mini but with a screen, less wires needed, and portable. A desktop would be better suited since I didn't have a computer in my room (the mini is in the living room, 1/2 owned by me). I wanted wireless, which the mini does not have. I wanted to try out the portability aspect which right now I have no use in. Also boot camp interested me. After re-evaluation, an intel mini would have been the correct choice (save money). But since the Macbook is all the intel mac mini is and more, I'm satisfied.

Mac mini, MacBook, Mac OS X (10.4.7), 1GB, 1.25GB Ram (respectively)

Posted on Sep 9, 2006 9:51 PM

Reply
2 replies

Sep 9, 2006 10:30 PM in response to Dale_Nx26

i'm reaching the one month mark so ill give some of my impressions that coincide or contrast with yours:

liquid effect on shutdown-i noticed it too, not like it bothers me, just something i actually noticed, i think its normal.


trackpad-i love the two finger scrolling and right click options, but now that i got the wireless mighty mouse i love the optional right click and and the ability to zoom with the scroll is really usefull


battery-ive been getting 4hrs-4.5, pretty impressed with it so far


airport router-i have to leech of my neighbor (across the street) b/c my network doesnt reach my room, using the macbook in the exact same spot where my desktop pc's wireless USB thingie is, i get double the signal on the macbook than on the desktop (desktop can barely load a web page, macbook runs internet just as fast, if not faster, than my mom/dad's desktop pcs right next to their router


applecare-i agree the phone wait has been ridiculous (i had the sleep instead of shutdown problem-easily solved by resetting the pvram and pmu) but once i got through they were incredibly helpful. i think its funny that i was on hold longer for the applecare part of tech support (i didnt have my enrollment # cuse it was never mailed) than it did for the actual tech support problem

this is my first mac so my overall impression (once the wierd thing with the going into sleep when shut down and not waking up w/o taking the battery out was solved) has been unbelievable. i hope to never buy a PC again. ive had every windows operating system made and im thanking god i'm not going to experience vista.

Sep 9, 2006 10:42 PM in response to JSwerdy

As ive said in other threads my macbook is in intensive care, but despite all this im enthralled by apple. my time with laptops is temporary, and i just need this unit to last me at least 3 years but i will be getting an apple desktop (no imacs im done with integrated displays) but while my computer was working, it was amazing. it was the best laptop i ever owned, and hopefully when its back from its repairs, it still will be. i will admit that given my situation, its hard to recommend this particular computer to anyone.

the liquid effect of the LCD is normal it happens on all macbooks and macbook pros. if youre doing work that requires you to have a good view of contrast you wouldnt be looking at your monitor at an off angle, so its only an issue to anyone observing beside you.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

My Review of My MacBook

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.