BasementJack wrote:
... and seems more intuitive for messing with effects, do you generally recommend one GB version over the other for use editing podcasts?
Also, and I'll likely ask this as a separate question, but it looks like you've also got a book on Logic X - Whats the general opinion of GB 6 vs GB10 vs LogicX as it relates to podcast / interview editing?
I cannot generally recommend one or the other because it is unfortunately not a black/white decision. It all depends how much you are affected by the points in the "Good News" or "Bad New" section.
The Good New
Honestly, I never was a big fan of the user interface in GB6. It had conventions that didn't follow a standard DAW interface and concept. Besides the look (which is a personal taste) GBX now follows the new Logic workflow which is more DAW-like. However, it misses a lot of features (some of them were there in GB6) which could be a deal breaker right there.
Think about a car company that upgraded their two car models (GB6 and LP9) to the newest electric car technology (Logic Pro X). Their old cheap Diesel engine model (GB6) is now GBX, similar to the big model. The downside, however, in the GBX model, they took away the stereo, the AC and no more cup holders. So you have a nice modern electric car but with some major short-comings. If you liked your stereo system, then you might continue driving your old diesel model until they add those features again. Until then, you might be happy with the old models, especially if you rely on cup holders.
The Bad News
Besides being all new and shiny with new (Drummer) toys, there are some major, major drawbacks with the new GBX. If you are affected by those limitations, then GBX is definitely not for you.
- No1: Elimination of Podcast, Movie and Magic GarageBand features. The Podcast omission is the most baffling, because Apple could add that great feature to Logic to keep feature parity.
- No2: Logic Plugins: GB6 had access to all those non-AU Plugins. These where the original Logic Plugins and they cannot be freely accessed anymore. Major bummer.
- No3: No Aux sends. Although GB6 had a very limited Aux Send feature, it was enough for many basic Projects. Now that is pretty much gone.
- No4: No Mixer. At least this feature was also missing in GB6. However, a standard mixer is not that compacted to understand, so don't understand Apple's reluctance to introduce this important music production feature to GarageBand.