I couldn't agree more.
Total overkill over sampling/recording analog audio, even with using good audio equipment.
Same for cassette tapes. The frequency range for CDs is greater compared to cassette tape, also.
Even with Dolby B or C activated,
Also, with either cassette tape or vinyl, condition is, also, an issue with audio fidelity.
WIth vinyl, it is the stability of the vinyl material, itself, as well as condition of the audio grooves and the quality of the tracking needle.
WIth cassettes, even it the cassette were not played too much and stored, relatively, well in a cool, shaded and somewhat dust free environment, tape can over time shed its iron oxides from the cassette tapes' metal oxide adhesive coating on the tape medium affecting the tape's overall frequency reproduction.
This can, also, be exascerbated by how dirty/clean the playback heads of the tape deck are.
There are lots of variables when recording digitally from analog audio sources.