Hello Nate
I too have found your posts really helpful, and completely agree with your comments ....
"Apple has created a serious eyestrain and productivity concern for many users with the introduction of Yosemite, and we should not IMHO be put in the position of hunting for kludged solutions to overcome it. It is a technical problem which requires a technical solution."
Leonardo Da Vinci is reputed to have said "Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication"
Certainly in design terms simplicity is perfection ...... Yet in it's attempts to make Yosemite 'look simple', the most basic aspects of usability seems been compromised, and Apple has made life just way too complicated. If it wasn't so sad it would be laughable.
I am a professional designer who expects my Mac to function as a serious workhorse, (not some sort of super-sized iPad) and allow me to get on with the job in hand. Yet I am finding that Yosemite is impeding my ability to work effectively and quickly. Trying to work around it's visual limitations, is an infuriating distraction. As well as eyestrain I am developing RSI as a result of all the extra key tapping from 'zooming in and out' just to be able to see what's on the screen. It certainly doesn't feel very sophisticated!
I own several different Macs, and rather than finally ditching an ancient Power Mac Quicksilver, running Tiger (which my IT guy advises is obsolete), I have gone back to using it in favour of struggling with my new MacBookAir running Yosemite. By comparison the ui is so much more user friendly, and the applications are so much simpler (without the accumulated bloatware). So much for progress.
For all that 'new fangled' stuff such as internet, email, phone I now tend to use (shhh....) a Samsung tablet and phone*. For me the winning advantage of the Samsung Tablet over an iPad, is that the keyboard has navigation cursor buttons < > which makes typing so much easier ...... I guess we are back to the Steve Jobs mantra that 'form follows function'.
Actually what is very obvious after using a touch screen on a mobile device, is that going back to a portable device, (such as the MBA) that relies on a track pad or mouse seems very, very old fashioned indeed ..... I think Apple are behind the curve on this.
The genius of Steve Jobs was that he understood that to achieve good, relevant, usable design, ruthless editing is just as important (if not more so), as good ideas. Apple seem to be getting distracted by too many 'good' ideas that lack real relevance.
Keep up the good work Nate
Regards
(*N.B. to my surprise, all my contacts and calendar stuff syncs perfectly courtesy of a google email account, and everything connects via Dropbox, Evernote and Inkpad)
Please excuse my earlier post - I took to long to edit it - if anyone can tell me how to remove it I would appreciate it. Stupid Apple yet again. Not user friendly