MacBook Pro (Retina, 15-inch, Early 2013)
Processor: 2.7 GHz Intel Core i7
Memory: 16 GB 1600 MHz DDR3
Graphics: Intel HD Graphics 4000 1024 MB
IOS 10.10.3
Since upgrading to Yosemite from Mavericks, I have encountered numerous issues. The most pressing one is the random force-ejection of my external hard drives. I have encountered this problem only when using my 1-3 TB external WD Passport drives (I have tried several, some brand new!) connected to a USB3 drive on my Macbook. The problem does not exist when using 8 GB and 16 GB thumb drives.
After the macbook force-ejects my external hard drive, it occasionally attempts to automatically re-mount only to again be immediately force-ejected. Oftentimes following a force eject, the external harddrive image is still present in the finder and on the desktop, but when I click them I receive a message that I do not have permission to view them. I cannot eject the drive using the 'eject' button next to drive icon in Finder, dragging the icon from desktop into trashcan, nor by CNTRL+Right Clicking the icon on the desktop and choosing 'Eject', nor by choosing the eject option from Finder's File menu! Even if I have completely unplugged the drive from the computer, the icon persists and shows the folder size if I choose 'Get Info' by right clicking the icon. When this happens, if I try to shut down the computer through the apple menu, it can take anywhere from 10-30 minutes to complete the shut down (during this time, a black screen with spinning white lines appears). Following this excruciatingly long shutdown process, it can take upwards of 10 minutes to start up again, lingering on the grey apple screen with a bar showing progress at about 30%. Upon startup, the disks automatically force eject again and the cycle is repeated.
I have tried several things to fix this unacceptable issue, which I have listed below:
1) In Energy Saver, I have unchecked the 'Put hard drives to sleep whenever possible' button for both Battery and Power Adapter.
2) I have completely disabled spotlight for all hard drives, including the ones that I am having trouble with. This helped somewhat so that now I can occasionally access the hard drive for 10-40 minutes before it force ejects at random, but the problem persists.
3) In the event that my external hard drive force ejects itself and still shows the icon on the desktop and in Finder, I follow these steps, which has a pretty good success rate for me, although the drives continue to be force ejected at random:
-Unplug the external hard drive
-Hard shut down by holding down power key
-Reset PRAM & SMC
-Restart computer with external hard drive plugged in
I followed another workaround that was listed here: Unplug external hard drive and hard shut down. Reset SMC. Replace the USB3 cord on the external hard drive with a USB2 cord, plug USB2 cord into USB2 port, plug USB2 port into computer's USB3 drive. Restart computer.
This has worked for me so far, but the transfer rate is still extremely slow as I am now using USB2. Hopefully this will solve random force eject problems. I will update, either way.
This problem has persisted for weeks, and while these workarounds helped me when I was in a pinch and needed to access the files immediately for a project, I can no longer work with this system as it impedes my ability to complete my work. For this reason, I am considering downgrading to Mavericks which did not give me this issue.
Before I do so, I wanted to check and see if there is any advice from other users in the forum. I have just downloaded 'Mountain', and have not yet had success with that.
Thank you for taking the time to read this and (hopefully!) provide some feedback on this issue.
(I am forwarding this from another thread (External hard drive ejects randomly) that I had started before I found this one)