Best photo processing and editing software for an amateur

Hello,


I am very much an amateur photographer who aspires to reach the ranks of an enthusiast some day 🙂

I have no processing experience and (very) little editing experience, but enjoy taking pictures and would like to get into optimizing them.

I shoot micro 4/3 in SF jpg+RAW. I have a lot of RAW files hanging around, quite a few shots I would like to process and edit and would like to learn to make the shots reflect the the actual image my eye saw (or to help set the mood).

I use a macbook pro and a mac mini.

In your opinion, what would be the best combination of user interface, navigable learning curve, usability and reliable impressive performance in regards to RAW processing and photo editing.

I do own Pixelmator (have tried but didn't dive in yet). I also have a copy of Aperture (never used). But before I really start to learn a system I would like to know if there are their other better processing or editing software options for someone like me? Again remembering that UI and user experience (but with still great results) are a premium.


Also, does anyone have an idea of how capable the upcoming OS X Photos app will be for amateur/enthusiasts?


Thanks!

Mac mini, OS X Yosemite (10.10.1)

Posted on Nov 28, 2014 4:46 PM

Reply
14 replies

Nov 29, 2014 6:47 AM in response to seanfrombronx

Aperture is a good application for amateur to professional use. It is reasonably priced. Apple used to offer a 30 day trial to let you get your feet yet. Since you already have a copy you might as well use it. You could also get support from the Apple Communities. Aperture offers ways to organize your photos (Places and Faces). It also offers quick adjustments to the files so you can adjust with one click.

Nov 29, 2014 6:57 AM in response to seanfrombronx

SF jpg+RAW.

Check, if your camera is supported by MacOS X and Aperture:

Apple - Aperture - Technical Specifications - RAW Support

Not all cameras are supported.


Aperture and Pixelmator serve different needs. Together they are a great combination.


Aperture will help you to develop your RAW photos to perfection and to adjust them, and also organize a growing library of photos. Tag them with metadata like captions, ratings, keywords, location information, share them, create books. Pixelmator as an external editor will add the ability to add graphics or compose several photos into one.

Nov 29, 2014 7:16 AM in response to seanfrombronx

When starting out with mac - I tried a free restricted version of photoshop 6 that came with my Printer -- and then purchased 7 as it was easy to use during minor editing and allowed advanced editing. Now running Photoshop CS3 - and from this site CS3 still will run with Yosemite while IPHOTO and APERTURE have to be updated and on on there way out.


I also had a restricted license copy of COREL PAINT on my old mac (license allowed for a trial run of work before you had to purchase it - also liked that as it had additional functions on the artistic side for modifying pictures.


As both are expensive - & was worried about backward compatibility during a software update - went with Photoshop.


Also, apparently IPHOTO and APERTURE are being replaced by another piece of software (think its pictures) with either you may be on the update train.

Nov 29, 2014 7:37 AM in response to notcloudy

Also, apparently IPHOTO and APERTURE are being replaced by another piece of software (think its pictures) with either you may be on the update train.

Aperture and iPhoto will be supported during the Life Cycle of Yosemite. Only, there will be no new major versions of these apps. The new "Photos" app will be Apple's new photo library application. And it will be possible to migrate Aperture libraries and iPhoto libraries to "Photos".

Nov 29, 2014 4:42 PM in response to seanfrombronx

If you are interested in taking classes - before purchasing anything check with local colleges as to what they offer in Photography and editing and what software is required - bet its PHOTOSHOP.


PHOTOSHOP also has various online tutorials/training.


Don't know about now, but when I purchased CS3 I also bought the printed manual - as I really don't like on-line help.

Dec 4, 2014 4:19 PM in response to seanfrombronx

Just FYI - Did some research on creative cloud


You can download a copy of photoshop and use it free for a month - if you don't like it don't subscribe.

The software resides on your computer so you can work off-line.

The monthly subscription includes updates so you do not have to keep purchasing lump sum updates and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Once a month the software will get updated subscription status from Adobe allowing you to continue to use the software.


I found the frequently asked questions through ask.com as adobes site like apples has a lot of stuff and nonsense when all you really want is to find the information on it.


See http://www.adobe.com/products/creativecloud/faq.edu.html

Dec 4, 2014 4:42 PM in response to SierraDragon

Crazy expensive Photoshop? For $120/yr you get that and Lightroom and some other miscellaneous stuff. That's trivial compared to what we used to pay for licenses. It's true that some find that expensive, since perhaps they don't need it, or if they economized by skipping versions, etc. But many of us are getting a great deal with their stuff. They have much better educational discounts than Apple by orders of magnitude as well, and extend those benefits to a wide range of academic situations. So check that out if you take the suggestion of going to a class on PS.


Photoshop may be too difficult for some, and too hard to learn for some amateurs, but it is the standard in photo image editing. Period. The stand alone perpetual licenses used to run hundreds and hundreds of dollars, but Adobe has really discounted it with the subscription. There are more plugins, presets, and other add-ons for LR/PS than any other software. Ditto for tutorials, etc. If you take classes at schools in photography, that's what you'll be using. You really can't go wrong with it. But it's sorta like Word; some just hate the thought of using it and never will. I find that these days LR plugins do a lot of what I used to do in PS, especially MacPhun's products, which do layers! They are the bomb, and their products work with Aperture, LR, PS, and some others.


I presume Apple's whatever new Photos thing will be free, but maybe not. It might meet your needs. Meanwhile, Adobe, Phase One, Corel and every other maker of photo software provides demos, so try a bunch and see what you like.


I also use micro 4/3 and it took Apple roughly half a year longer to come out with RAW processing for my camera. Everyone else, e.g. Adobe, is MUCH faster. Perhaps that won't matter, but I would prefer going with developers who are more committed to photography than Apple.

Dec 5, 2014 5:19 PM in response to notcloudy

I appreciate your frustration with the site. They actually have a lot of good info there, but for some reason (marketing) it's rather hidden.


I'd suggest you do what I do when I really want info about a product; I go straight for their support page, not the product info page. And I especially hunt down any user forums. So I'd straightaway go here if I were researching Aperture. Similarly, check out https://forums.adobe.com/community/creative_cloud for info about Creative Cloud (and criticism) and the forums on LR and PS as well. There are other non-Adobe sites that sponsor forums on these products as well. Unlike Apple's discussions, people are authorized by Adobe to answer questions there. So it's not just Adobe fanboys, but semi sponsored fanboys, which means they perhaps do have the right answer and/or have accountability of some sort to Adobe. There are probably more Aperture to Lightroom switchers than the reverse, especially these days, so you'd get a different perspective over there.

Jan 4, 2015 11:46 AM in response to seanfrombronx

Sean - Since you already have a copy of Aperture I would go with Aperture for now. This will enable you to get familiar with photo editing software and also offers good integration with iPhoto and your Apple devices. No one really seems to know what Photos will offer so I am going to wait until it comes out and see if it meets my needs....my suspicion is it will, since for me the integration is a big plus if there is adequate organizing and editing capabilities. If not, the other software options will still be available and maybe even upgraded from a version you would buy today.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

Best photo processing and editing software for an amateur

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.