Looks like no one’s replied in a while. To start the conversation again, simply ask a new question.

Mac Pro 2012, GTX 770, OSX 10.8.5 and 4K monitor

Hi everyone,

I am not sure, so it's better to ask.


I have the previous model of Mac Pro (12 core 3.33GHz) with GTX 770 plugged in. The system is 10.8.5. Till now, I was using Apple Cinema Display HD 30", but I would like to change it to a better monitor with 4K resolution if it will be possible. The question is, will it work fine with this card and under this version of OS?

I don't want to upgrade the OS, because well… I don't like how it looks like, so this version of OS is quite important for me.

The graphic card itself can run this resolution without a problem, but what a bout the OSX? Everything will be OK?

Mac Pro, Mac OS X (10.6.8), 4.1 2.26 8c upgr. to 5.1 3.33 12c

Posted on Feb 25, 2015 2:43 AM

Reply
14 replies

Feb 26, 2015 7:46 AM in response to norm123

Hi Norm,


it is because of the computer model or because of the system - I mean because of the version of OSX installed on my computer?

Look here: http://create.pro/blog/mac-pro-51-4k-monitor-vs-imac-5k-create-pro-face/

They connected 4K monitor to the Mac Pro 5.1 and the only difference (which I see) is the version of OSX and the graphic card, but the mine card could also run 4K resolution.

What do you think?


Regards,

Marek.

Feb 26, 2015 10:14 AM in response to MarekO

Can you narrow down displays you are thinking of and in your price range?

Dell, Asus, LG, Samsung - along with this ASUS are also some other 4k displays listed for comparison.

http://www.amazon.com/ASUS-PQ321Q-31-5-Inch-4K-Monitor/dp/B00DJ4BIKA/


The one article with 5,1 was using AMD Radeon R9 280X 3GB

can't see why GTX 770 would not (unless Mountain Lion issue and you need SwitresX?)

http://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/8355/switchresx


Display Support:

4096x2160Maximum Digital Resolution1

2048x1536Maximum VGA Resolution

One Dual Link DVI-I, One Dual Link DVI-D, One HDMI, One DisplayPortStandard Display Connectors

4 displays Multi Monitor

Yes HDCP

Yes HDMI

http://www.geforce.com/hardware/desktop-gpus/geforce-gtx-770/specifications

http://www.geforce.com/hardware/technology/



Some of Apple's articles I wonder if they are written by the marketing department instead of tech (and whoever does, they should have an engineer to proof-read)

Feb 27, 2015 3:23 AM in response to The hatter

Hi The hatter,

nice to read you again. I wasn't here for a few years (so I am sure you don't remember me), but I remember you.

I've almost decided to buy the LG 31MU97, but just before one click to buy it, I stopped thinking will it be working with my Mac? And as I know Apple, I am not sure. Of course it will work with all new equipment, but with the older ones, even with a new graphic card?

The above mentioned type of monitor is not a must have. I can also consider another model: Dell, NEC etc. The most important for me is the size: minimum 29 inch up to 31 inch. My budget is up to USD 1800. So, I need the best monitor as it is possible in that price. If it is necessary I could also buy R9 280X card, but as I am using Adobe AE quite often, I think that the card with CUDA is a better one.


And… I don't know who at Apple is writing some stupid nonsense at their website - f.e. according to Apple's my computer (2009 model upgraded) can only have 32GB of RAM. But I have 80GB and under this system I can even have 96GB.

Feb 27, 2015 4:24 AM in response to MarekO

MarekO I do recall your name from before, just not the particulars.


Apple never updates specs on maximum memory, hard drive compatibility and other things. Even the fact that the ATI 5770 worked in any and all Mac Pro models outside of audio support, which was a godsend to many like me with a 2006 1,1.


Someone wrote that one GPU required 800MHz DDR2 (mine came with 667MHz) so people wanted to just swap the memory figuring that was what the graphic card needed. Nothing to do with memory speed. Everything to do with EFI 32 vs 64 (and no mention of UEFI or the more accurate and technical).


Okay


Did you read where the ASUS monitor customer had trouble? and that a firmware upgrade helped? Notice also the horrid customer support they first received and how miniDisplayPort vs DisplayPort?


I am sorry I don't have more experience or own a 4k monitor 🙂 Would like to, sure.

There have been - especially a year ago - there was a lot of "hand-wringing" over which brand and models of 4k would even work on a 6,1 - let alone work with GTX 770 (which is supported on your Mac when running Windows btw in 4k mode, so there!)


Here is help and to wet your appetite:


Anyhow, can't help but be reminded today when I discovered how to enable 60Hz 4K MST on Nvidia cards. Seems Apple didn't want the cMP rubbing elbows with nMP so took to some more deliberate knee-capping. (how Kerrigan-esque !)


I put the Asus PQ321 in MST mode and Nvidia GPU can output 3840x2160. And if I run the "OpenClOcenawaves" bench, I get 61fps. Anyone familiar with this app knows it has been locked to refresh rate for last 2 OS builds. You can unhook it with Quartz Debug, but for my purposes, better not.


scottrichardson /showthread.php?p=19427891#post19427891

/showthread.php?p=19427891#post19427891


Exciting stuff!! Though to be honest I had no idea we couldn't already plug a 4K display into our cMP's and get 60Hz support. I thought that was what they fixed in 10.9.3?


Only on AMD cards, been there since 10.9.2 I think. They stacked the deck against Nvidia, they have been limited to 30Hz. Artificially as it turns out.

SST displays are a different story.


........ ......


Suddenly it's 1984 - Nvidia 4K 60 Hz support is there, Apple turned it off ( 1 2 3 4)

MacVidCards

So AMD vs NVidia stuff. And can't cannibalize AMD on cMP without also damaging Dxxx so the R9 280x and above are a safer bet.

People have been (trying) to tell me that the CUDA vs OpenCL is "history" and not as big an issue (though AMD drivers and Adobe apps on nMP 6,1 and those Dxxx's are (or have been) a real issue for the last year. It can take 12-18 months for changes, to make their way into the market and next Adobe upgrade. So they have had their year!

Feb 27, 2015 6:08 AM in response to The hatter

One more "pet-peeve" is graphic drivers. Only bundled in OS, no support for last year's OS.


Aug 2014: MacVidCards: Titan in Yosemite running 4K @ 60 Hz on MST using new Web Driver for Yosemite DP4
Works on GTX680 as well....even a GT640 w/DP can do it. Darn Apple and their forced...everything

http://forums.macrumors.com/showpost.php?p=19428276&postcount=4

http://forums.macrumors.com/showpost.php?p=20727447&postcount=84


Included cables not supporting features dept:


if you plan to run the (LG) 31MU97 at 4096x2160 60Hz, you will need to buy a heavy gauge high quality display port cable($50-$70) because the one they provide flickers and blacks out from time to time cause it's pushing the data limit. It's kind of funny they give you a cable that wont run monitor at it's full spec...


" Dell P2715Q should work with no issues since it's running SST.

" I have tried the LG 31MU97 and the Samsung 32"4k with the 680 and had no issues getting 3840x2160 60hz working with plug and play all the way back on 10.8.5 through 10.10. "


-----------------


I imagine that Nvidia is like us in that they are overwhelmed by the variety of different 4K displays and how many of them seem to act differently despite in theory adhering to same standards.

I have heard from someone with a Dell UP2414Q who says that the 4K fix still works on that. It is possible that Nvidia has only tested on that and those of us with other displays are just out of luck, at least for 10.10.2

===============


More variables than x and y it seems.

Get out spreadsheet to cover display monitor, OS, GPU


For me, go AMD so you can see and use your 4k display - in an ideal world, people have used AMD for display monitors and left GTX or Quadro to handle the CUDA / GPGPU workload which has worked just fine. Only issue Is the measly 2 x 6-pin aux power provided natively.

Feb 27, 2015 4:49 PM in response to The hatter

You are The Master! ;-)

As usual very helpful and accurate. Thank you for spending quite a lot of time for helping me.

Still I am not closing the topic, because now I will try to collect and understand all the info you wrote me.


So, simplifying - it looks like, that if I want to stay with 10.8.5 I should buy R9 280X card, the 4K monitor and the high quality display port cable, am I right?

Now, which monitor should I buy….. I think I will spend the whole weekend. The ACD 30" I was using for 7 years, so it's better to make a right choice for the next several years.


I found the seller of the R9 card at ebay (from Germany which is an advantage due to shipping costs to Poland), who assured me that the card will work in my specific configuration. The price is attractive and the seller very good (I've already bought something from him): http://www.ebay.com/itm/121568115576?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m142 3.l2649


I will also write an email to my GTX 770's seller, writing him the same question. A year ago, I paid for this card more than for R9, so I wouldn't be very happy if I have to switch it. But if it is necessary I will do it.

I am not a big fan o new Mac Pro, therefore I don't have any plans to change my two Mac Pro's 4,1 - both upgraded to 5,1 3.33GHz 12-core, therefore I will stay with them as long as it will be possible.

BTW. I am very proud of this upgrade because I did it by myself (I am using both computers in my small company). It was quite a nice fun, especially with doing firmware upgrade and measuring pads under the heatsink. But finally I was amazed how the computer started a new life with 2 times higher performance.


It looks that this link: Suddenly it's 1984 - Nvidia 4K 60 Hz support is there, Apple turned it off ( 1234) is deleted by Apple… :-(


Marek

Feb 28, 2015 1:56 AM in response to MarekO

Only if you:

- previously "purchased" Mavericks. If so go to the Purchases section of the Mac App Store and doewnload the installer. Then make bootable USB install device and boot to that device and format the startup disk and install. You will get 19.9.5

- You have a backup made with Mavericks or a clone of a Mavericks installation. Just retore from the Mavericks backup or format the existing HD and clone it from the clone.

Feb 28, 2015 2:46 AM in response to The hatter

Barefeats on 5k but of course 10.10.2 with a GTX 980 ($600+)

http://barefeats.com/mpt5k.html


The only pro app not happy was After Effects CC's ray-trace 3D which gave an error when we loaded the Robot project.

That appears to be an Optix issue, not a 5K issue.


WHERE TO BUY THE GEFORCE GTX 980 and other GPUs
You can buy a 'vanilla' GTX 980 on Amazon.

For a modified GTX 980 with Apple startup screen, visit MacVidCards.

If you favor an AMD GPU like the Radeon R9 290X, MacVidCards can modify it to run at PCIe 2.0 bandwidth in your Mac Pro tower.

It does not run at 5K on the Dell 5K display but it does run at 4K (60Hz) on that display.

Mar 5, 2015 8:10 AM in response to lllaass

If I didn't "purchase" the 10.9 system earlier, it is not possible now? What if somebody has too old computer to upgrade to 10.10, but wants to upgrade to 10.9? Is it not possible?

So, the only what I can do is to find this version in torrent? Really?

Well… typical for Apple - very simple things are not possible. I am using Apple computers from 1995, but from a few years I have this feeling that nothing normal is possible to do - the only answer is just buy a new equipment. You want to change a battery in laptop - not possible, you want to add a RAM i some models - not possible, you want to change the graphic card in new Mac Pro - not possible. Just buy and look how they are pretty and don't even try to think that you can change anything. An the same with the apps: Shake - killed, Aperture - killed, FCP - well… FCPX. OMG! But wait! There is an iWatch! Amazing!...


But even if I will download the 10.9 from somewhere, I suppose I will have another problems: will the FCP 7 and Motion 4 work with this system? Usually I work with After Effects, but still sometimes I use Motion for some things. Still I didn't switch to Premiere and I work with FCP, although I know that I should do this because using Apple apps has no sense. So, do you know will those apps work with 10.9.5?

Mac Pro 2012, GTX 770, OSX 10.8.5 and 4K monitor

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple ID.