Thought I already converted my AOL Screen Name to an email address for Apple ID years ago, but...
Does anyone remember back in ~2010 iTunes/Apple made users convert AOL Screen Names to email addresses for an Apple ID? I converted then, now Apple support is telling me that I still need to convert that particular AOL Screen Name. I think they are mistaken, but I'm willing to jump through some hoops if it saves my music. I haven't used my AOL Screen Name to sign on to iTunes for YEARS, so of course, I don't know the password, so I tried the "Forgot?" link to reset my password for my AOL Screen Name. The password tool can't find my AOL Screen Name being used as an Apple ID, which makes sense to me, because I still think I've already converted, but I am afraid I will lose a LOT of my purchases due to Apple support telling me differently. I have purchases going back to at least 2006, and I don't want to lose those purchases that were made on my AOL Screen Name (before I converted it to an email address in 2010, I promise).
Thanks in advance for any ideas/help.
Windows 7