Linc Davis wrote:
1. You have a security problem. Don't trust Apple; trust me instead.
Unfortunately, Apple's track record on security is very poor. Like others, I used to tell people to trust Apple where security was concerned. But I was wrong. That was before Apple introduced major security bugs and left users vulnerable for years. Currently, all versions of OS X from 10.7 to 10.10.2 have active security vulnerabilities that Apple says it is unable to fix. All of this is publicly documented.
The value in this site is that no one ever says "trust me instead". Anyone is free to add a reply and help build a consensus. You are the only one who regularly tells people to not trust that consensus.
2. You're incapable of following straightforward instructions. Something terrible will happen! Do what I tell you.
If these argumentswere to believed, you would be at the mercy of any Internet criminal who says the same thing. Don't make the mistake of thinking that because this is an Apple website, the content is endorsed by Apple. Comments have been posted on this site by actual malware attackers, advising people to install their malware, and of course, assuring them that it was safe and that the attacker was trustworthy.
While anything is possible, I have never seen anything like that happen on this site. If it did, there would certainly be an overwhelming consensus against said attacker. Sometimes representatives from antivirus or "clean up" software attempt to defend their legitimate, albeit not recommended software, and they are the ones attacked by the consensus.
We have no control over who reads the suggestions on this site. Maybe they are capable of following those instructions and maybe they aren't. We have a responsibility to all of them to give them the safest suggestions we can. I have seen people recently attempt to follow such instructions and accidentally delete all of their data. I have seen someone recently attempt to follow your instructions and delete all of their e-mail. If people don't have backups, losing all of there irreplaceable data, photos, documents, etc. would be terrible indeed.
You're being asked to weaken or give up your skepticism of strangers, which is the only dependable defense you will ever have against Internet crime.
Sorry, Linc. Apple Support Communities is not a hotbed of internet crime. As anyone can see form this very thread. It is heavily moderated by Apple staff. It is designed to provide a safe venue for people to get advice from strangers. That is the whole point of it.