Q: My recent calls appearing on another iPhone!?

>> and by fact, I mean something that is in writing

Whether or not something is in writing has nothing to do with whether or not it is a fact.

Fact: (Merriam Webster) - http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fact

• something that truly exists or happens : something that has actual existence
• : a true piece of information

JAta2 wrote:

 

>> and by fact, I mean something that is in writing

 

Whether or not something is in writing has nothing to do with whether or not it is a fact.

 

Fact: (Merriam Webster) - http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fact

• something that truly exists or happens : something that has actual existence
• : a true piece of information

 

 

In this instance, it's a figment of your imagination.  Where does that fit in with Merriam Webster?

JAta2 wrote:

 

>> No.  I know because of the untrue allegation made by the poster.

 

What "untrue allegation" was made by the poster?  That he called Apple UK and was given certain information that you didn't like?

 

>> Is it really necessary for you to constantly throw out insults?

 

You and others basically call him a liar and defame him, now you think I'm insulting you by pointing this out.  Really!

I am Elvis's nephew

Proof now and again would be nice, proof of anything you say would be an improvement. Proof rather than unsubstantiated nonsense.

To be fair to everyone, there is no evidence one way or another that this is either a feature or a bug. I'd be happy if anyone could post evidence that this works as intended or evidence that this is a bug. Sadly I don't think any of this evidence exists so this arguing IMO is futile and gets none of us anywhere.

Apple are very clear about it. 1 user 1 ID

Apple's FAQ

That doesn't cover if call history sharing is a feature or a bug. That's my point - no more, no less.

Interpret it as you wish Dunc, 1 ID per person is the manufacturers recommendation. You can do what you want, it makes no difference to me.

I am one user one ID. I follow Apples recommendations.

I will reiterate. My statement was only that Apple have not confirmed this is a bug. They have not confirmed it is a feature. Arguing the toss helps no body.

EDIT - and that is aimed at everybody who claims it is one or another, not just you

I mean no disrespect with that response and feel that logic is correct right here, reality however not entirely.  And then again I can not find info anywhere that iPhone is an actual phone and mac book air is an actual computer. At least not directly from Apple. So for the time being I intend to agree with you, until Apple tells me that iPhone is an actual phone - I will stop making calls. Looked over all of the specifications and the word phone only exists in one of the green apps named like that.

http://www.apple.com/iphone-6/specs/

DuncBob wrote:

 

I am one user one ID. I follow Apples recommendations.

 

I will reiterate. My statement was only that Apple have not confirmed this is a bug. They have not confirmed it is a feature. Arguing the toss helps no body.

 

EDIT - and that is aimed at everybody who claims it is one or another, not just you

Bob, there are no prizes on offer, do it as you wish, I won't follow your lead as I have no problems with IOS or iCloud.

So do as you wish.

I HAVE A SUGGESTION

Go to Apple's site and look at every single word they have ever written regarding the iPhone and IOS.  Take a look at any of the materials which came with your iPhone.  Download the manual for your iPhone.  Pay special attention to the sections on Family Sharing, and Continuity, and Handoff and iCloud and iCloud Drive.  If you find anything which speaks of the terrific NEW feature where those who have more than one iPhone on the same Apple ID now have the convenience of all of your call logs on one phone appearing on the other - please report back here immediately and tell us where it can be found.

On the other hand, read again every single post in this thread and search, with appropriate search terms, all of the other threads on every public forum in the universe which is Apple specific, and look for posts from people like myself.  The post might likely be along the lines of - "hey, what happened, I've had my business phone and personal phone on one Apple ID for years (because I am ONE PERSON) and all of a sudden my all logs are appearing on the other phone."  They might go on to explain how it is a great inconvenience as they now have a more difficult time in keeping personal life and business life separate.  When reading these posts try and figure out why the poster would go on an Apple specific public forum and ask for help with what they perceive as problem. 

If after doing this you still believe this is a FEATURE which is designed by Apple and therefore a very good thing, come back here ONE MORE TIME!  Write your findings in this post and then, please leave this message thread and never return!  This message thread is for people who think the duplicative call logs are a problem and a bug, and are here looking for answers.  My mailbox is inundated with posts from people who offer no solutions, but simply want to beat others over the head because they have a different conclusion then those of us looking for answers.

Why don't you just go and buy an Android?  They're perfect!

Csound1 wrote:

 

JAta2 wrote:

 

>> No.  I know because of the untrue allegation made by the poster.

 

What "untrue allegation" was made by the poster?  That he called Apple UK and was given certain information that you didn't like?

 

>> Is it really necessary for you to constantly throw out insults?

 

You and others basically call him a liar and defame him, now you think I'm insulting you by pointing this out.  Really!

I am Elvis's nephew

 

Proof now and again would be nice, proof of anything you say would be an improvement. Proof rather than unsubstantiated nonsense.

I met your uncle the other day.  He was in a 7-11.

Sorry Gov. I do not plan on repeating your errors.

Go buy some thing else if iPhones do not meet your needs.

Which one, we have many uncles in these parts.