The Mystery of the Cracked MacBook Display

I love my new black MacBook with the 13.3” glossy screen. It's less than 3 months old. I take exceptionally good care of it. It's never been dropped, bumped, or mishandled. It's rarely left its shelf next to the stereo where it wirelessly manages all my digital music. Yet, for no apparent reason, and in the presence of four trustworthy witnesses (not counting myself) who had just enjoyed my first iPhotos slideshow, the screen suddenly and inexplicitly changed from the familiar iTunes library while playing an iTunes playlist, to a work of abstract art. My friends and family were at first captivated by what we assumed was an unwanted but nevertheless artistic software glitch. The music kept playing and we actually took pictures of the screen because it was so weirdly beautiful and surely impossible to reproduce. But when a restart failed to change the screen image, awe turned to dread. A stop by the Apple Store the next day confirmed the problem was a cracked screen. “Cracked screen?” I repeated, stunned. What could have caused that?” I’ve been using lesser-grade laptops for international travel that have taken serious abuse and I have never experienced, much less ever heard anyone else complain about a cracked screen. “Must be some design flaw. That’s disappointing. I had expected more from Apple. Oh, well. It’s under a great warranty. How long to get it fixed?” The reply from the Apple Genius was stunning. “Cracked screens are the result of accidents. They’re not covered under warranty.” I was speechless. Accident? Impossible. Had it been so, the explanation for the bizarre screen image would have been obvious to all five of us. I realized I needed to speak to the manager. “How much force would it take to crack a screen,” I asked. “I can’t quantify it,” the manager replied, “but dropping it or a blow to the screen with a sharp object would do it.” I won’t recount the tense exchange that transpired between me and the store Manager, whose comment, “I want to believe you,” translated to this customer as “you’re obviously lying” and instead jump to the proposed solution offered... Ship the defective machine to Apple Repair and have them determine if there is any evidence to prove there was a manufacturing defect (note wording: “evidence to prove there was a manufacturing defect,” not prove there was an accident). If there’s no proof it was a defect, the repair will cost over $700—about 40% the value of the machine. To his credit, the manager will waive the $100 inspection fee should I decline the repair.

So, here’s my question. Has there ever been another recorded incident where an LCD screen just cracked?

As a research analyst I appreciate how unbelievable my story must have sounded to the Genius and the Manager and maybe even you. But on-line discussion boards indicate this has happened under the most innocuous of conditions, like lifting or moving the machine by the screen rather the base, but even this level of mistreatment is not possible in this case. I believe some sort of stress on the screen due to improper frame alignment (the plastic screen hinge did have a slight squeak) might cause the screen to eventually fracture under normal use. Might there be something especially fragile about the new glossy screens? Can anyone provide a reasonable explanation as to what happened?

MacBook, Mac OS X (10.4), Black 13" Glossy Display

Posted on Nov 1, 2006 8:02 AM

Reply
19 replies

Nov 1, 2006 11:16 AM in response to RockvilleResearcher

I've responded to your post on Macobserver:

http://www.macobserver.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=49271

which I see you've already responded.

I might add, I read it over again, and the slight squeak may be indicative of a slight defect in how your machine was received. Though it is hard to say. The shipping issue could have happened as your machine was delivered to you or the store you bought it from.

Regardless how it happened, I think your best bet given the age of the machine is to purchase AppleCare, and take it up with AppleCare and their customer relations department.

The fact a squeak was noticed at the beginning makes me wonder if there was an initial problem with shipping.

Nov 2, 2006 10:51 AM in response to RockvilleResearcher

I have been having my own little display problem. I keep my laptop in a bag, inside of a protective laptop case. Yet I have this scratch across the screen that won't come off. It appears to come from the bottom line of the keyboard.
I have had so many problems with these new Macbooks. I'm really disappointed in Apple with this line. I have to get my keyboard replaced (the bad plastic), my computer mysteriously turns on and overheats in the middle of the night, and randomly shuts off when it gets frustrated. But why would I get that scratch if it's in a protective case? Just how fragile are these computers anyway? Why would they make them so fragile?

Nov 2, 2006 11:04 AM in response to Abi Kleinsmith

Abi,
Normally they aren't that fragile. You must have had something that fell in the case which scratches the screen. A piece of pencil lead might do it, or if you ever had food in the case, or any foreign article. Something that fell into the keyboard could have fallen out and scratched the machine's display. If you don't eat over the keyboard, and don't do your fingernails over the keyboard, and there is nothing which could have been in the bag, well you might want to contact AppleCare. Regardless, please start a new topic thread so someone can help you if these suggestions don't.

Nov 8, 2006 9:43 PM in response to RockvilleResearcher

It's almost scary how much of your situation is just like mine. Just over a month of purchasing the new macbook, the same thing happened to me! I was sitting down with my wife, she closed the macbook to put it to sleep. When she came back a few minutes later (and I was sitting next to the macbook the whole time) and opened it up, she showed me all the colored lines and asked me what was wrong with it. I told her to reboot and thought that would clear it up. Well I was wrong and we took it back to the Apple store where we purchased it.
We were absolutely shocked when they told us the screen was cracked! They treated us like liers saying we must have caused the "physical damage". We handle that computer like we handle our baby!!! I have been on the phone fighting with Apple to get this fixed but of course they won't!
Like you, I believe there is some defect with this screen. Help me help you. I have never been as passionate about fighting a company over a product as I am about this.
I feel this is so wrong and refuse to pay the 774.00 or whatever crazy price they say to fix this screen.
I'm trying to find out how many other people are having this same problem.

Nov 28, 2006 8:12 PM in response to Junebuggy

hi there, i also JUST experienced this.... however it has not taken over my entire screen, just the bottom right corner leaving my computer not totally worthless. i am terribly upset by this though - i like many others have said, take very good care of my computer, and use it almost exclusively around my home. prior to this screen cracking, i noticed that when i move and then set my macbook down on a surface the screen sometimes forcefully flys backward (possibly due to a weak hinge?) but until now, i never really thought anything of it.... and no i was not throwing it down! i have not yet contacting my local apple store where my computer was purchased, but i have a feeling it is not going to go well.

Nov 29, 2006 8:20 AM in response to RockvilleResearcher

My problem isnt as severe as yours as it has not effected the display as it has yours. My issue is this...there are two stress lines where the screen hinge connects to the body of the laptop. You can see it when the lid is closed. I am the most anal person when it comes to my computers especially ones that cost as much as this one. When I do carry it out, it travels in two protective cases placed inside a backback. I have never dropped it and always treat it like a delicate flower. Why in the world do I have to cracks in it? I have no idea. The only effect it has had on the display is when I first turn it on it will flicker for the first few minutes then it seems to be fine. I love my macs, but why... why.. why! I would expect this from a dell laptop that cost me $600, but the fact is ... it seems to only be happening to the ones I pay thousands for... Whats the dealeo?

POWER G5 Mac OS X (10.4.5) & MacBook

POWER G5 Mac OS X (10.4.5)

Dec 2, 2006 8:45 AM in response to PLEASEHELPME99

I've seen enough of these complaints that I believe a percentage of people are being honest and their screens really did spontaneously crack. The way LCD panels are manufactured is on a large substrate called a "mother glass" where several panels are made at one time. When the processing is complete, the glass is scored and the large substrate is cracked along the score lines into individual panels. I am not sure how the scored and cracked edges are finished, but if the panels aren't processed right the possibility for a crack migration point (micro-crack) will exist from the edge.

I would think that Apple could screen to tell the difference between a panel that cracked from the edge, especially if from the hinge area, versus an impact to the center, which would constitute physical damage and not be covered by warranty. If your screen honestly cracked for no apparent reason other than normal use, I would keep pressure on Apple to deal with the problem as a warranty issue.

Dec 4, 2006 2:49 AM in response to RockvilleResearcher

Have read this topic with great interest as 7 days ago I purchased a new Black MacBook. The Macbook has never been out of the house and has been treated as my pride and joy! Having gone to use the MacBook yesterday, I opened the screen to find a crack in the shape of a reverse C runing fro the top left to bottom left of the screen. I'm gutted! Trying to get in contact with Apple support now but have been on hold for over 30 mins which is doing my rage the world of good. Will send further response when I manage to get in touch with them.

Dec 7, 2006 8:33 AM in response to RockvilleResearcher

Hi, well I have the exact same problem.. The ironic thing was that I was actually talking to a computer support at the time it happened... They asked me to reboot my computer and I did... and something not so funny happened, a bunch of coloured lines appeared all over the screen and I could do nothing.. I'm so ******* fed up with Mac.. I bought my computer in end of June.. In August I got the problem where the computer randomly shuts off itself, it took them 3 weeks get it sorted. After another month I got the problem of not being able to recharge my battery.. It took them 4 weeks to get it solved. After having my computer in just about one week after the battery thing, the screen is dead or at least very colourful! It will take them about 4 weeks to manage that problem… Hey I thought I spent my money on a computer that would be problem free.. That’s why I bought a Mac since I’m moving to India next week.. Well now I have to move without my computer… I’m just hoping that they will give me a new computer so that I can sell it and buy a sony vaio instead! I have soon been owning my Mac for six months and it has been on repair for three.. That is 50% of the time I have had it.. **** I haven’t even had time causing it damage! I really loved my Mac, the system is fantastic but they really need to get their **** together before I ever gonna consider buying a Mac again… So yes I have had the same problem and it is not because of “physical damage”, if they haven’t cracked it during the months it has taken them repairing it… I guess I have had more or less all the possible problems there is… not very happy.

Dec 7, 2006 9:38 AM in response to NasTh

1) the colored lines doesn't sound like a cracked screen. A few weeks ago, after one of the updates, some people started having this problem. It was solved in a strange way, whereby you had to go and change the resolution of the screen to something (anything) else, then restart and change it back. Look for 'colored lines' in this forum to find the exact procedure. It was a problem easily solved, and not one that required a 4-week repair!

2) if that's not your problem, and your screen really does need replacing, and it really will take 4 weeks, why don't you call Customer Support, explain what's happened so far, and tell them about your imminent move to India. There's a very good chance they'll give you a replacement if your story can be documented and your problems have been severe and repeated.

3) Don't kid yourself that a VAIO will necessarily be any more reliable. Until now, I've had only VAIO laptops, and while I loved the way they were designed (but not the windows OS on them), they were hardly immune to hardware failure! In fact, my last one shocked my hands every time I used it, for more than 4 years! I also had hard drive failure, fan failure, a case that never latched properly, and the paint flaked off the wrist rest. And Sony customer service is TERRIBLE, requiring sending it away for long periods of time for repairs.

Dec 10, 2006 10:50 AM in response to RockvilleResearcher

My son's black MacBook developed a diagonal crack across the screen two months after purchase. There were no marks on the screen or computer to indicate impact. There were not even scratches; he has treated it very well. The machine has always been transported (to/from/around his college) in a Brenthaven backpack purchased in advance of the MacBook.

I have noted a flexibility in the top lid. If one does not grip it at the center when opening and closing, it appears that a torsional force transmits to the LCD, which ought to be enough to crack it with repeated application.

For now, he opens and closes it by gripping the lid at its center. The lid does not twist that way. We'll hope that practice avoids a second failure. I'm cautiously optimistic but am not confident that the lid is sufficiently rigid to protect the LCD without undue care.

FYI, the repair cost about $160 — at an Apple Store. I was told we were only charged labor because the machine appeared so clean and because it was so new.

This thread has been closed by the system or the community team. You may vote for any posts you find helpful, or search the Community for additional answers.

The Mystery of the Cracked MacBook Display

Welcome to Apple Support Community
A forum where Apple customers help each other with their products. Get started with your Apple Account.